Riggsie:
You may be aware that Hula Grill and Leilani's are owned and managed by the same folks.tsrestaurants.com. Haven't dined at either, but, we enjoyed Duke's Canoe Club, Waikiki, lots. Good formula and food.

The Bay Club in Kapalua.

Sarento's in Kihei.

Both romantic -- Sheraton's dinner under the Stars

The Aloha Mixed Plate, which is next door to the Old Lahaina Luau, is great!

Ferraro's at the 4S is very good. Great ocean front setting with live music. Very nice. Sarento's was also very good as well. Both were highlights of our trip for upscale dining. We also tried Cheeseburger in Paradise and were disappointed by the food. Run of the mill pressed burgers that can be found anywhere; really nothing very special however the location on the water was nice. Food quality was definitely not as advertised in Fodors.