Big Island's Green Sand Beach from Hilo vs. Waikoloa?
 

What's a better drive to the Big Island's Green Sand Beach, coming from Hilo or from Waikoloa? We wanted to find the path that's more scenic, and less time-consuming. We'll be staying on both sides of the island, and we'll have plenty of time to explore the volcano and other sights, so we aren't planning to make any major stops along the way. How long do you think the trip will take?

Also, do you need 4WD to get to the beach itself, or does it just save you the hike? If anyone can elaborate on their green sand experience it would be very helpful!

Waikoloa to South Point is longer, but also more scenic than Hilo to South Point. The west route takes you up about 3500' and provides some great overlooks of South Kona. But the east route has its own beauty, if barren lava flows and great views of Mauna Loa are your thing.

A 4WD is not needed to get the green sand beach, but will save you about 5 miles of hiking. Take the wide dirt trail that heads east about 1/4 mile before the very end of South Point Road.

Thanks! I thought I read somewhere that you need a permit to go hiking there, or that a $25 deposit was needed to get a key(?) to access the beach? Is this true? If so, where do you go to do this?

None of that is true. Local Hawaiians sometime hang out at the end of South Point Road (or in the small parking area adjacent to the trail that leads to the green sand beach) and try to convince tourists that permits, keys, parking fees etc are required. They're not.

South Point is a remote area and vehicle break-ins are common. If you park and hike to the beach instead of drive, make sure you don't leave any valuables in your car (including in the glove box and trunk).

Thanks, fdecarlo! You've been a great help!