Ventanas vs. Palmilla vs. Punta Mita
 

Trying to choose a luxury resort for Winter and have narrowed it down to Mexico between Las Ventanas vs. Palmilla in Cabo, vs. Four Seasons Punta Mita. Any input from those who have been to any of them is appreciated. Not taking kids, emphasis is on service, views, beaches*, health club, food, rooms and golf.

have only been to the 4 Seasons, so cannot speak to the other two, but I can say that I can't imagine lovelier views than at Punta Mita, and the golf course is just gorgeous. The health club is nice, well equipped. Service is just unparalled.
The beaches will be better at Punta Mita if you plan to swim -- most of Cabo's beaches are not swimmable, too rough.
Winter would also be the perfect time for Punta Mita.
I'd imagine that Punta Mita's rooms might be slightly less "luxe" than Palmilla's or Las Ventanas. & while I found the food very good, I wouldn't say it was amazing!