Fodor's Travel Talk Forums

Fodor's Travel Talk Forums (https://www.fodors.com/community/)
-   Europe (https://www.fodors.com/community/europe/)
-   -   Quad-band GSM phone for $15 (sort of) (https://www.fodors.com/community/europe/quad-band-gsm-phone-for-15-sort-of-721696/)

Robespierre Jul 17th, 2007 04:40 PM

Quad-band GSM phone for $15 (sort of)
 
Right now, T-Mobile is offering new Pay-As-You-Go customers a Motorola V195 for $39.95 (free shipping) with a $25 calling credit.

It <i>appears</i> that it can be used in Europe for 99&cent; per minute (once International Roaming is enabled), and it <i>appears</i> that T-Mobile will send you the unlock code for your phone (if you ask enough Customer Service reps until you get the right one).

The PAYG agreement only stipulates that you activate the phone within a month and buy $10 worth of airtime, or you &quot;lose&quot; the number (and your $25 credit). But if you only want to acquire it for use in Europe, you might not care.

Here's the deal: tinyurl.com/2el8nm

carrolldf Jul 17th, 2007 05:49 PM

You will not be able to use the T-Mobile Pay-as-you-go service in Europe at any price as there is no international roaming on TMO PrePaid except for Canada and Mexico. The web site is a bit confusing but trust me on this one unless you don't mind spending the money just to find out it doesn't work. (The $0.99 per minute roaming in Europe is for a regular TMO post paid account.)

If you purchase this phone and keep it active, after 90 days TMO will give you the unlock code for free and you would then be able to purchase a pre-paid SIM in Europe to use in it.

Robespierre Jul 17th, 2007 05:59 PM

Well, yeah, I hear that.

I also hear that if you get the right CS rep, you can get International Roaming activated on Day One as well as the unlock code emailed to you at the same time.

Given T-Mo's record with keeping their premium services locked down, I don't (automatically) doubt anything I hear - regardless of how their policies read.

No two of their agents appear to be working from the same script.

julies Jul 18th, 2007 05:46 AM

Phone gurus help me out please. We are not big cell phone users, so we have only one cell phone, the T Mobile pay-as-as-you-go plan with a botton of the line Nokia phone that is not quad band. I have been wondering about getting a different, more expensive, phone so we would have the capability of just insering a SIM card when abroad.

1. This offer wouldn't work out for us unless we got another phone and account. Correct?

2. My idea of upgrading to a different phone with quad band wouldn't work out either because we just want the pay-as-you-go plan rather than being locked into an expensive contract. Correct?

Thanks. I am kind of a technology idiot.

Robespierre Jul 18th, 2007 06:23 AM

I'm not sure. The way I read the T-Mo PAYG &quot;contract,&quot; it looks as though the subscriber can cancel it at any time simply by not replenishing minutes once a month. The phone number is dissociated from the SIM, and you're off the hook.

This being the case, there would be nothing to prevent you from getting another phone and a different account. The Terms and Conditions seem to say that a single subscriber can have up to two accounts active simultaneously.

Captb93 Jul 18th, 2007 02:14 PM

Robespierre,

I just got off the phone with my T Mobile and she definitely stated, after checking with a supervisor, that European roaming is not available to the Pay as You Go plan. Only option is to unlock the phone and purchase a Global or country sim card. I know you stated that the reps are not all on the same page.


Should I try again? How did you get the .99 roaming deal for the Pay as You go Plan?


welltraveledbrit Jul 18th, 2007 02:44 PM

When I bought a T-mobile pay as you go the website seemed to suggest you could have international roaming BUT when i called to activate I was told, and I asked them to check with a supervisor) that there was NO internationa roaming for their prepaid customer.

I've been meaning to call them up to unlock it before my August trip to Europe, thanks for reminding me!

Robespierre Jul 18th, 2007 04:19 PM

In the course of my research, I probably talked to a half-dozen reps and supes, and no two of them gave me the same story.

I don't have a prepaid contract, so I just went to my.t-mobile.com and turned on International Roaming myself. This was about three years ago.

Every day, there are spirited discussions on howardforums.com regarding what exploits of leaks in T-Mobile's business are possible.

shellio Jul 18th, 2007 06:18 PM

Julies, if all you want is an unlocked quad-band phone to use in Europe, go to eBay and buy one of the literally dozens you will see there. I've done it twice in the last year and got one for $45 and the other for $60, shipping incuded. If I had wanted to spend the time playing the eBay game I could have spent less.

Once there (France, in my case) go to an Orange phone store (SFR is another possible vendor with lots of locations) and buy a SIM card and some euros of additional credit, which will vary depending on how much you expect to use the phone. The SIM card should run about 40 euros as I recall. This is a pay-as-you-go plan with no longterm contract required.

Then buy a 7 euro calling card from a tabac which allows you to call the US by dialing a local number. While this uses minutes against the phone credit, the long distance charge is something like 6¢/minute.

Girlspytravel Jul 18th, 2007 08:35 PM

There's no way in hell that a pay as you go plan would allow international roaming-that doesn't even make sense, because the company would lose money instantly on such a deal, and cell phone companies NEVER offer a plan where you benefit and they lose money on the deal-really!

Julie-do as Shellio says, go on ebay and buy yourself a good UNLOCKED quad band phone-if you travel a lot internationally, I tell you it's a godsend-I have a Motorola Razr, and I just change up my SIM card in whatever country I'm in (actually, with my Italian telecom Italia SIM, it automatically changes to Orange when I get to France-didn't know that, but that's what happened).

When I was in Thailand for example, I could call back to the states for like 7 cents a minute, and it was 3 cents a minute inside the country. It's really worth it-plus, getting a phone card saves you even more money-since you can use it with your quad-band phone of course, and get hugely discounted rates to call back to the US.

One thing about getting a SIM card in Italy-they will take your passport and make a copy of it-everyone buying a SIM card in Italy has to have a passport record on file-which is one of their post 9/11 security measures-don't know about France.

Kristina Jul 18th, 2007 08:40 PM

Girlspy-Did you buy your SIM in Italy or before you got there? I didn't know you could use an Italian SIM in Thailand. Or is it some kind of Global SIM? I'm looking for a card I can use all over the world too, but I'd prefer not to wait until I get to Italy to activate it.

Girlspytravel Jul 18th, 2007 08:46 PM

No, No. I have different SIMs-one in Italy, the other bought in Thailand. But you can't get a SIM (don't think) until you get to the country in question-and you wouldn't be able to use it from the US. It doesn't take long at all. And then, you SAVE your SIM for when you go back-just take out your TMobile or whatever SIM you have in your quad-band for your plan here in the States, and insert the SIM of your choice.

Kristina Jul 18th, 2007 08:53 PM

Ah, ok, I was confused about your post.

It is possible to buy Italian SIMs in advance online, albeit much more expensive. The upside is that you have a number to give out in advance and (supposedly) a phone that will work on arrival (handy if you are late). However, I've read that sometimes these cards are not actually active on arrival, forcing one to still go to a mobile store. Truely global SIM cards are out there too of course, but no where near as cheap as buying individual ones in country.

Girlspytravel Jul 18th, 2007 08:58 PM

I didn't know that about global SIMs-I'll have to look into that-and as for getting an Italian SIM before leaving-my guess is you would have trouble getting it to activate on arrival-best to go in the shop and make sure it's working by having the seller call you on their phone while you're there to test it.

Kristina Jul 18th, 2007 09:09 PM

If you're interested in global cards, you might look here:
http://www.telestial.com/sim_cards.php
The &quot;passport&quot; cards are global.
However, they're not cheap-you certainly pay for the convenience of being able to have a single (Eastonian!) phone number all over the world. They have other benefits too like free incoming calls in certain countries, voicemail, free incoming text msg. But the per minute charges can be crazy.

xyz123 Jul 18th, 2007 11:43 PM

Although a long time proponent of the use of global cards, you have to be aware that the cost to call these global cards has gone through the roof recently as the telcoms are doing everything in their power to try to discourage their use and to try to force you and me to pay their ridiculously high roaming rates.

Many ld carriers in the United States now charge from 50¢ to well over $1/minute to call mobile numbers in Liechtenstein, Estonia and Iceland....and even calls to the Isle of Man mobiles in some cases are very high. While you get the free reception of calls, your callers will pay through the nose.

BTW the telestial passport offer is simply a rebranded Estonian offer.

Because of the higher incoming rates, even using callbackworld which used to be a great idea has become asininely expensive.

Hopefully with the eu regs coming in, some of this may be alleviated in the near future.

Incidentally, the only international sim right now which is worthwhile to use with cheap calls to the USA with callbackworld is O9, an Icelandic card where the charge, at least temporarily, remains 16¢/minute. Using callbackworld with United Mobile which used to be 14¢/minute until this past April is something like 52¢/minute. Their business which was built on these cheap calls to Liechtenstein mobiles will probably take a beating now.

You can read about it on www.prepaidgsm.net.

sandi_travelnut Jul 19th, 2007 05:03 AM

I have a Motorola Razr from Sprint. Can I also buy a SIM card in Italy and use it there?

xyz123 Jul 19th, 2007 05:10 AM

Most likely not...sprint is not a gsm carrier.

Girlspytravel Jul 19th, 2007 05:28 AM

Right. The key is getting the unlocked, quad-band manufacturer phone that is NOT branded. That's why I bought my Motorola Razr on ebay (I got it a couple of years ago for at least $100.00 less than the going price-it costs more to get the unlocked manufacturer's phone-it's old now, but it works just fine where ever I go in the world).

sandi_travelnut Jul 19th, 2007 06:16 AM

I am not an Ebay shopper so excuse this question: do I search on &quot;GSM phone&quot;? also I assume one of the key things to look for is that it's unlocked. Anything else I need to look for when shopping on ebay for one of these phones?

Girlspytravel Jul 19th, 2007 06:21 AM

You need to buy an unlocked quad band phone-I'd say, preferably Motorola,-but you have to make sure it doesn't say Motorola Sprint or Samsung AT &amp; T or some other service provider quad band phone, because those are locked. It has to be manufacturer only quad-band.

rkkwan Jul 19th, 2007 06:23 AM

sandi - &quot;Unlocked quad band GSM&quot; will give you about 200.

&quot;Unlocked tri band GSM&quot; will give you also about 200. Make sure the frequencies include 900 and 1800. Some won't have 850. If you're planning to use AT&amp;T Wireless here AND abroad, you need quad band.

&quot;Unlocked dual band GSM&quot; or &quot;unlocked 900 1800 GSM&quot; will also give you some. Can't use it here in the US with those.

sandi_travelnut Jul 19th, 2007 06:25 AM

Excellent advise. Thank you. With issues I had in Rome in January I vowed to never travel again without a cell phone.

Girlspytravel Jul 19th, 2007 06:27 AM

I just looked, and saw a nice Motorola new V3 quad band Gold Razr phone at the buy it now price of 99.98. What you will get is a European plug phone, and they will include the US adapter (that's what I have).

Girlspytravel Jul 19th, 2007 06:30 AM

I wouldn't even bother with a tri-band-there are areas around the world where you can't use tri-band-if you're going to buy a cell phone, I say, make it quad-band or nothing, because quad-band will allow you to use it whereever in the world you happen to be-from Laos to England.

Robespierre Jul 19th, 2007 06:44 AM

&quot;There's no way in hell that a pay as you go plan would allow international roaming-that doesn't even make sense, because the company would lose money instantly on such a deal...&quot;

Um, they've got your money up front. You're being charged 99&cent; per minute every time you hit SEND. I don't see where the company loses money.

Sher Jul 19th, 2007 06:50 AM

Sandi. I just recently purchased a quad band phone on Ebay for $35.

It was used, so it was a leap of faith. I searched GSM phone.

It is a unlocked, quad band and the description said something like can be used all over the world. I am trying to remember if it said unlocked and I think maybe it did.

Make sure like rkkwan says that it is not linked to any of our companies.

I received the phone and I happen to have a universal SIM which I inserted and dialed my home number and it rang. So I know the phone will work. I didn't complete the call.

Girlspytravel Jul 19th, 2007 06:54 AM

No they DON'T have your money up front. Pay as you go is not as profitable by far to a company as a one or two year typical contractual plan-you think they're going to give you pay as you go AND allow international roaming, which costs them a lot of money? Don't THINK so.

Any way, I just checked on ebay again-I was wrong-that Gold Razr for 99.99 is logoed AT &amp; T. However, I DID see what I was suggesting: a black V3 Razr, FACTORY unlocked quadband (those are the keywords) for $199.99. As the site states, these phones do not lose their value, because you can use them anywhere, without having to mess up the software by getting a branded quad-band, and then having to get a special code to &quot;unlock&quot; it. No thanks.

dsd123 Jul 19th, 2007 07:56 AM

I recently just got back from Italy and when I went I got a phone from onesimcard.com. I think the price is about the same as people are talking about here ($100 for a phone+SIM card) and calling is 69 cents a minute, definitely better than 99/minute. You can also rent a phone there for a little less.

I think this is probably a safer option than buying one off ebay, hoping it works, then buying a SIM card there and hoping it works. Buying it from these guys I know it's going to work, and their customer support was really nice.

xyz123 Jul 19th, 2007 08:01 AM

Just a point...

Not everything sold on ebay is second hand...there are some very good merchants there from whom I have gotten great prices on gsm phones and have never had any difficulty with anything I've bought there.

rkkwan Jul 19th, 2007 08:07 AM

Pre-paid international roaming works for many international carriers. Nothing special about them. They just &quot;eat up&quot; your prepaid amount quickly. Yes, they'll cost a lot more, sure, but it's up to the user whether to use it or not.

I don't know why T-Mobile USA don't allow it. But come to think of it, they don't even allow domestic roaming onto other GSM network where there's no T-Mobile's own. So, coverage of T-Mobile Prepaid in the US is not as good as coverage of T-Mobile Post-paid in the US.

Robespierre Jul 19th, 2007 08:21 AM

No they DON'T have your money up front. <b>Of course they do. That's why it's called a PREPAID plan.</b>

Pay as you go is not as profitable by far to a company as a one or two year typical contractual plan <b>Why would they do it if it didn't make money?</b>

-you think they're going to give you pay as you go AND allow international roaming, which costs them a lot of money? <b>Why would IR cost the company any more for PAYG as for prepaid? They would charge 99&cent; for either. (And where T-Mobile is the European carrier, they don't have to share the 99&cent; with anyone.)</b>

Don't THINK so. <b>Your mere opinion isn't persuasive. Facts would be.</b>

xyz123 Jul 19th, 2007 08:21 AM

It is nonsense that international roaming is expensive for the carriers...it is a big money maker at our expense.

In theory, international roaming includes the payment your home company has to make to its roaming partner for use of its network.

Well let's take an example. I have a T Mobile USA plan which allows their World Class roaming at 99¢/minute or fraction thereof....well part of it is to compensate the roaming partner.

So I go to the UK and T Mobile US's preferred roaming partner is, believe it or not, T Mobile UK (what a surprise)...so part of the 99¢/minute or fraction thereof they charge me is to compensate T Mobile UK for me, a T Mobile US customer, using their network. Well when T Mobile US compensates T Mobile UK, since both are fully owned parts of the same conglomerate (Deutsh Telecom I believe)...it is akin to taking money from their left pocket and putting it into the right pocket.

The fact is several UK carriers on some pay as you go plan charge as little as 4p/minute timed in one second intervals for calling the USA from a UK prepaid (if you don't believe me checkout Mobile World, Orange Call Abroad or T Mobile UK bundles)....they seem to be happy getting the business so of course this idea that 99¢/minute or fraction thereof is not a rip off is absurd and also the idea that international roaming not be allowed on prepaid is also junk.

Johnmango Jul 19th, 2007 08:39 AM

Actually ... I believe it is not true that if you have a GSM quad-band phone you can &quot;use it wherever you happen to be - from Laos to England&quot;.

Japan uses w-CDMA technology so your GSM phone will not work in Japan. But Japan is an exception not the norm.

I am no expert in cell phone technology, but I read that n Japan you can still rent or buy a w-CDMA phone and pop your GSM sim card in it. here's the article:

&quot;No. GSM is not deployed in Japan. If you just would like to use your GSM SIM card (i.e. make/receive calls with your usual number) in Japan, buy or rent a W-CDMA (UMTS) phone, put your SIM card in it and it can roam in Japan. See below about W-CDMA roaming ...&quot;

http://euc.jp/misc/cellphones.en.html#tech

Girlspytravel Jul 19th, 2007 09:17 AM

The contractual plans are much better deals, generally speaking, than pay as you go-and &quot;Pay as you go&quot; although it SOUNDS GOOD, IN FACT, ENDS UP COSTING MORE THAN A CONTRACTUAL PLAN-YOU'LL PAY FOR EVERY LITTLE CHARGE, RATHER THAN HAVING IT INCLUDED IN A PLAN.

As for a quad-band phone, the fact of the matter is, you CAN use it all over the world WITH TWO EXCEPTIONS: Japan and Korea-where you will have to rent one of their UMTS/CMDA phones. OR, you can go on ebay and find a Motorola quad band A840 which works on BOTH the 2100 mhz capacity in Japan and on the GSM bands around the rest of the world. And given the cost of renting phones in Japan, I'd say buying one on ebay would prove to be far more economical.

http://www.mobiledia.com/phones/motorola/a840.html


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 01:09 PM.