Uma

We visited Italy twice, in 2005 and 2006. I fell hard for Rome, Sorrento, the Amalfi Coast; harder for Venice and Florence. But I left my heart in Paris when we visited in 2009. We returned last month to reclaim it. We'd already seen many of the major sights our first go round and been overwhelmed by the art, architecture, food, history, culture, people; loved that we could walk all day; loved how beautiful and vibrant the city is.

This was a special trip to celebrate my husband's 60th birthday. We spent 5 nights in Paris and 4 in Provence, with Avignon as our base. We splurged -- on flights(with the help of frequent flier miles), hotels, restaurants, a driver for Provence. Here are some notes and recommendations:

PARIS

We split our time -- 3 nights in the beginning at Hotel d' Aubusson in the 6th; 2 nights at the end at Hotel Relais Saint Germain. We had stayed at the Aubusson on our first trip. There is much to recommend here -- the location, minutes from Pont Neuf and the islands; the lovely interior and spacious, comfortable rooms; the warm and helpful staff; the nightly music at Cafe Laurent. Relais Saint Germain is located a short distance away, on the other side of Blvd. St. Germain and closer to the Luxembourg Gardens.
Much to recommend here, too. A very charming boutique hotel with very small but lovely
common areas and a friendly staff. Breakfast was included here. Our room was beautifully furnished. As guests of the hotel, we were able to get a table at Le Comptoir.

We returned to familiar haunts -- Luxembourg Gardens, Eiffel Tower, Notre Dame, Ile St. Louis for ice cream at Berthillon, walking along the Seine, taking a Vedettes du Pont Neuf river cruise. And added the Rodin Museum, the Deportation Memorial behind Notre Dame, Les Invalides, St. Sulpice, Versailles (where we took advantage of the little train to get around the grounds, and enjoyed hot chocolate and mont blanc at Angelina's); all places we had missed on our first trip.

We dined at Reed, on cold zucchini soup, mushroom risotto, cornish hen and cheesecake. Others here have raved about this place. We enjoyed meeting Catherine Reed and we liked her food, though this wasn't our favorite place.

We had wonderful meals at Le Violon d' Ingres (roasted vegetables with pork; sea bass with almonds; John Dory; multiple amuse bouches; a grand marnier souffle and millefeuille with caramel sauce followed by caramels and tiny madeleines), where the service was stellar (our waiter escorted us out of the restaurant and got us settled in our waiting taxi); and at Le Comptoir (red rice with beets, carrot flowers, parmesan and horseradish foam; fingerling potatos, black cod; grilled breast of veal with roasted semolina and saffron; a cheese tray, and yuzu, sheep milk ice cream and pepper timuk(??, but delicious).

We enjoyed the food and the diners on either side of us more than the service at
Josephine Chez Dumonet -- foie gras; artichoke hearts in butter sauce; delicious
boeuf bourgignon and a shared millefeuille.

While at the Aubusson, we breakfasted on quiche and pain au chocolat down the street at Eric Kayser, where we bought olive bread almost daily.

I dragged my husband on the great macaron and chocolate hunt -- back to Gerard Mulot where we had our favorite macarons the first trip, and then to Un Dimanche a Paris, Pierre Marcolino and Pierre Herme. The salted caramel macarons at Pierre Marcolino may have been my favorites this time. He savored a plenitude individuel (dark chocolate cake with chocolate mousse and salted caramel) from Pierre Herme.

One afternoon we enjoyed a "snack" of hot chocolate, tahitian tea and chocolate treats at Un Dimanche a Paris and, like groupies, had our picture taken with the owner, Pierre Cluizel.

I was left with vivid memories of things we had seen and done after our first trip -- the stained glass windows of La Sainte-Chapelle; Monet's vast canvasses at the L' Orangerie; the city from the top of the Eiffel Tower; the length of the Champs-Elysses from the top of the Arc; Notre Dame; Place des Vosges; the Luxembourg Gardens;
the wonderful paintings in Musee d'Orsay; the Mona Lisa at the Louvre; the city lit up on our evening Seine cruise. This trip, I am left more with memories of the people I encountered -- locals and fellow travellers.

Paris was no less magical the second time around. It is a city I could return to again and again.

Marija

So glad you had a wonderful trip. Your report brings back great memories. Thanks!

Kurosawa

I also discovered Paris in 2009 and returned this year to visit it again. I never feel like I have enough time there. It is so beautiful.

Why did you decide to switch hotels midway through your visit?

Uma

My brother in law has stayed at Relais St. Germain and highly recommended it. Since we were splitting up our time in Paris, with 3 nights on the front end, 2 on the back, and Avignon in between, thought it might be fun to try someplace new. Both hotels were very accommodating; left a suitcase at the Aubusson so we'd have less to haul on the train; it was waiting for us in our room at Relais St. Germain when we returned to Paris 4 days later. Would gladly stay again in either hotel. Give Aubusson the edge for their staff and Cafe Laurent, and Relais St. Germain for the room and Le Comptoir.

cigalechanta

Thanks for this report. Friends of mine stay at the Relais
St Germain and I dined with them at Le Comptoir. I love their room with the beamed ceiling. It felt more like a small apartment.Next time, try the mango caramels of Jaques Genin
at his beautiful boutique/cafe. They would leave a few in the rooms at the Relais.

Uma

Cigale, We were given mango caramels at the end of our meal at Le Comptoir, and I wondered if they came from Jacques Genin. We didn't make it to his shop this visit; on the list for next time. And yes, our room at Relais St. Germain felt like a cozy, well furnished apt.

cigalechanta

yes they are Jaques Genins, that's how we happened to go to his shop.

go_laura

Thank you for posting this report. I'm going to Paris for my first time in early May 2013 and I can't wait!

waterdog

We have also stayed at both hotels, but not during the same trip. We liked them both and have returned to each several times. One thing that we remember fondly is taking afternoon tea on a cold winter's day in front the huge fireplace at the Aubusson.

Uma

go_laura, am sure you will fall in love with this beautiful city. waterdog, we also had a late "afternoon tea" at the Aubusson(hubby had hot chocolate) each day in their lovely sitting room. It was a great way to unwind from busy days.

grandmere

It sounds like a terrific trip with great hotels and wonderful food.

denisea

You hit lots of my favs! I am so missing Paris?

latedaytraveler

ttt

Elainee

Our recent meal at Josephine was disappointing . Liked it in the past but would not go again. Miserable service.

denisea

Interesting...have always wanted to go to Josephine. Sad to hear you had bad service, Elainee.

We love Le Comptoir and are considering Relais St Germain for the next trip. It's easily our favorite area of Paris.