| xyz123 |
Mar 15th, 2011 04:10 AM |
ekscrunchy....maybe they've cleaned up their act. You can go through this forum and find various threads concerning a scam called dynamic currency conversion. This cancer started about 15 years ago in Ireland and has since metastasized to many other countries such as Spain and Italy. Normally when you use mc/visa, the charge is written up in local currency (in this case euro) and your bank follows a procedure to convert the amount to your own currency. MC/visa actually do the conversion and add a 1% fee to the official interbank exchange rate to protect against currency fluctuations. Many near criminal banks in the USA add a 2% fee to this even though they have nothing to do with the conversion. Other enlightened banks only pass along the 1% mc/visa fee (USAA) and there is even a bank that eats the 1% mc/visa fee and charges you at the prevailing intrbank rate (Capital One). But even with the 3% fee, it is far better than exchanging cash.
In any event, in this scam called dynamic currency convesion, the actual exchange is done by the merchant. When the card is swiped by the terminal, from its numbers, the computer recognizes the country the card was issued in. It then suggests to the merchant, using an exchange rate at least 5% above the in terbank rate, that it could convert the charge to US dollars and that would be the guaranteed charge. It would reaCH THE MC/Visa system already converted. Now here is where the illegality comes in. The merchant is supposed to ask you if you wish to take part in this scam that is pay a higher rate for the "covenience" of having the charge converted on the spot. The strongest recommendation is just say no but many people think how near it is the merchant is providing this "service". Of course the reason they do is they and their credit card processor split the profits from this overcharge. You most assuredly pay more.
Where the problem comes in is that mc/visa regulations allow dcc but state you must give permission. Many merchants just do it routinely and don't ask you if you wish it be done and pressure you into signing the sales slip where you waive your rights to appeal the conversion. If you notice, they have arguments ready why it can't be changed (local laws require dcc, once it's done it's done and the transaction can't be voided (it most assuredly can), they have no control over it, it was done by the terminal (as noted the terminal asks them if the sucker...oops customer wishes to be ripped off), the USD rate listed is just an approximation, and the famous no speak English).
A few times it has been pulled on me at this store but there's been a lot of bad publicity about dcc recently and maybe they've cleaned up their act (almost always in Ireland now, they ask). I used USD in this discussion but it can be any currency conversion. A Brit travels in euroland, they try to pull this converting euro to sterling..a Canadian they try to convert euro to Canadian dollars.
Finally, to add insult to injury. Many of the near criminal banks in the USA now charge 3% anyway, claiming the 3% fee is not a currency exchange fee but a foreign transaction fee.
You never win this game. Just say NO.
|