Dayle,

I agree totally. I want to see them crack down on the size/weight restrictions. But, with Alitalia having a 6kg (13.2# limit), with a roller carryon bag you could only pack 6# in it!

Love my rolling backpack. Best of both worlds.

Another vote for the combo. I have the Tumi rolling bag with tuckaway backpack straps and while I usually roll it, I like having the option of carrying it on my back for tube stations, train on-and-offs, etc. I agree with the reminder to haul the bag around for a while and make sure you can manage it.

If you get anything with wheels, make sure they are good strong wheels.

Good wheels can take most cobblestones.

Byrd

i used a different tactic during two month-long trips in Asia. I bought a middle schooler's book bag, expandable 18-incher, with wheels for $19.99 and figured it would last at least one trip -- and it's lasted through several more. it's very light and i roll that and put good day pack on my back for necessities. it's worked great. That way i distribute the weight and have toiletries/travel info/documents/umbrella/rain jacket, etc. in my back pack. The rolling school bag is light enough that i can lift it easily on to buses, trains, etc. Even traveling with a partner, one should be self-sufficient.

One heartfelt request should either of you opt for the backpack:

Please, please, please remember the dimensions of your backpack as you maneuver walking around other people--especially on trains, buses, crowded walkways, etc. I've lost track of how many times I've been whacked in the chest, back or face by a backpack-wearer turning around or simply walking next to me!

Of course, this doesn't matter hiking on trails (if not crowded, LOL), but when others are around, please be considerate.

Thank you in advance!

the debate rages on
;-)