Celebrity or ncl
 

I looked at Mercry and sky.both look good. any comments?

Depends upon what you are looking for. We think Celebrity is the best, but some people like Carnival. ((b))

Budman is correct. I prefer Celebrity to NCL but am going on the Wind 11/22/04 just for the ports, not the ship.

As an NCL lover...I must admit I have never been on a Celebrity (not yet)..and my criteria for a ship is what ports is it going to. m You will find many people who turn up their nose at NCL...I turn my nose up at RCI after my one experience..yechh

thank you, thank, you the ports about the same...iactually want to go to prince rupert and both stop there.

Celebrity is our choice three years running. Elegant but not stuffy, food and atmosphere much nicer than Carnival--unless you want to party-party-party every night in pretty casual surroundings.

I just came back from the NCL Wind and had a great time in the Western Carribean.

I am super partial to Celebrity...
food and service is terrfic..

Check and see which ports you like better...and price..

But , my vote is a definite CELEBRITY

Odd ball here.... but as nice as Celebrity is, I give the edge to NCL for dining options and entertainment. I prefer the NCL Sun.
Be warned though that all these type ships will charge you for everything even something as simple as bottled water. No comps here!

well i booked the ncl sky going to alaska... free style sold me. so give it to me good or bad,i plan on a nice trip