typical question :) which island? St. Martin, Jamaica or TCI
 

Hi,

Me, my wife, our 2 year old son, along with 2 friends decided to rent a villa in Caribbean Islands. Having been before at St. John, St. Thomas, St. Croix and Jamacia even for a few hours during a cruise trip, I have some experience regarding what to expect there. But for a one week vacation, I really don't know well enough to decide where to stay.

We are all ineterested in nice beaches, snorkeling and good restaurants. Night life or shopping are not our priority; but wouldn't hurt if available. We narrowed down our choices to St. Martin, Jamaica and Turks & Caicos.

Which one would you recommend and why?

Thank you

Turks & Caicos-hands down....the best beaches of the 3, SAFEST of the 3 ! Great dining as well

Having been to all 3 numerous times, Turks and Caicos! So kid/toddler friendly. You have the worlds best beach there. The beaches are clean, rock free and crystal clear (more so than your other choices) which 2 year olds love.

Another reason is the resort setup. Most are condos with full kitchens, yet treated like a Resort with restaurants and amenities. Great when you have kids.

Easy to get around, and one of the safest islands around. (much safer than your other 2 choices)

I have to agree with the posts above. T&C has everything you're looking for- gorgeous beaches, great restaurants, beautiful accommodations, but what is your budget?

I agree also. T & C is the best choice of the 3.

If snorkeling is a priority like you mentioned, TCI is probably your best bet as snorkeling option on Jamaica & St Martin are very limited. You'll find some on TCI, but for everything on your wishlist, ST John hits them all.

Not Jamaica (I love Negril but generally speaking I think it's a little too "adventurous" to be a family-friendly island).

Many thanks. We all agreed on TCI.

With a two year old hands down Turks.
Great beaches, restaurants, etc.
safety wise too.