madamepetunia

We actually booked PC but can still cancel. RP has an all inclusive special through September 1. I am torn.
We want to lie on a beach and sip good drinks and it be quiet and romantic and easy with really good food.
Any thoughts on which one?

blamona

What's the all inclusive special? Just a meal plan? Beacause PC offers meal plan too (which I highly recommend as it will save you money for same meals)

How many nights are you going? Have you considered a split? 3 nights at each?

Completely different feels from each other. PC on it's own island, RG is on the main island, Provo.

madamepetunia

RP's special includes food and alcohol. I honestly don't know that the price difference will be a whole lot different between the two resorts once said and done, it is just nice to not have to worry or think about the cost of every cocktail (as I've heard they are about $20 each!).
We are going for 5 nights and not really wanting to split.
The package at PC throws in breakfast and a couples massage and one night free, so I feel like it is a good deal as well. I am a little hesitant the food and drink will add up quickly…BUT at this point I am more torn on which experience we'd prefer…..

WWK

I don't know much about PC, since we stay in Provo, but my concern is the food. You say you want great food, but how are the reviews for PC? There are lots of amazing restaurants on Provo ( Coco Bistro, Bay Bistro, to name two) and it might be a shame to miss them!

valturks

PC will also give you a very very private island experience, and big emphasis on yoga, wellness, relax, chill. RP will give you some of that, but on Grace Bay and amongst other things to do and see - so depends on what you're looking for, as blamona suggested, perhaps you may consider a split stay.. have fun!