Snorkeling - St. Martin or Anguilla
 

Which has the best beaches for snorkeling??

You'll find better snorkeling off of Anguilla's beaches, however, the best in the area is actually off of Prickley Pear Island (accessible only by boat). You can do day trips there from either SXM or AXA.

Sorry but neither islands offer quality snorkeling. Anguilla though is a bit better.

We just returned from our first trip to St. Martin. The snokeling was almost non-existant. Go to the Virgin Islands if you want to snorkel, certainly not either SXM or Anguilla.

You're kidding, right? I've seen more fish at my local supermarket.

Well that's why I ask Newyorkergal... becuz I do't know. Trying to get as much info as I can before picking my destination.