Can someone make some restaurant recommendations on HI? We are open for anything. Also, we are planning a day trip over to Eleuthera and will probably rent a car. Any "must see" places over there?

Thanks!

Angela's Starfish for her conch burger. Get it to go and sit on one of the docks and enjoy the sunset
Sip Sip for lunch and drinks. Great view on beach side
The Landing for nice fish dishes
Rock House for a nice dinner
Blue Bar (outside) at Pink Sands for lunch
Valentine's for early evening cocktails watching the boats come in.

Runaway Hill used to be good so hopefully, someone will post from a recent visit.

I've become quite obsessed with the out islands...finally going to runaway hill in two months....cannot wait!

Barbuda!!!! It's not near any paths.
It is one of the few remaining undeveloped islands in the Caribbean. Mile upon mile of deserted pink sand beaches and lobster galore. There are 2 resorts on this island Coco Point Lodge and Lighthouse Bay Resort. There are guest houses in Codrington, the only village on the 62sq mile island of 1500 people.

How is Barbuda? Hard to get too? Romantic? How the heck is a person with little experience supposed to pick a place to spend a chunk of cash? The possibilities seem endless.

My wife and I love the Grenadines. Small islands, set in pristine waters, and less developed than many other Caribbean venues. I know that there are villas/apartments for rent on Bequia.

I know this is late but for others I would suggest Montserrat, Dominica or Saba for varying reasons.