Ok, so I need a car...from who?
 

Ok, after reading the responses to my earlier message and a lot of the other posts, I'm convinced I need a car....but from whom? I've looked at several national rental sites and gotten a few prices. Thrifty seems the cheapest but on another board someone complained about their cars and service. Any suggestions/experience with car rental agencies?

Which island?

helmsman, most of the car rental agencies on caribbean islands are smaller companies, one location only type places. If we know what island, maybe someone can refer a company. We've had good experience 2X with Delbert Hill on St. John.

Sorry...St. Martin/St. Maarten in December.

I can highly recommend Best Deal on SXM. I've been renting from them for years and you can book online.