Fodor's Travel Talk Forums - is you had to pick one? Fish Trap or Lime Inn?

Fodor's Travel Talk Forums (https://www.fodors.com/community/)

- Caribbean Islands (https://www.fodors.com/community/caribbean-islands/)

- - is you had to pick one? Fish Trap or Lime Inn? (https://www.fodors.com/community/caribbean-islands/is-you-had-to-pick-one-fish-trap-or-lime-inn-667933/)

Please excuse my typo "LoPster" supposed to be "LoBster".

Love the Lime Inn!

-Bill

Scott,

I just made my reservation on line and it was confirmed by email, pretty easy. Thanks!

Fish Trap was my favorite, and Lime Inn #2. Also loved Asolare and the view at Bordeaux (not so much the food or prices), Pannini and Island Blues (in Coral Bay)

fishtrapo and stone terrace...

We liked Asolare so much that we named our new boat Asolare!

Asolare has gone way down hill but is stuck high on a hill requiring a taxi--forget driving there-no parking.
It is overpriced, and new owners restaurant group who care only for bottom line. Its not a friendly place at all for me...its pretentious.

Stone Terrace has world class dining, Wine Spectator Award winning list, friendly, competent, capable and professional management, and walkable from many villas and a condo i stay at at gallows Point every month.

Time for only 1?
Stone Terrace.

and even if i had time for 12, i still wouldn't go to Asolare

“Asolare” meaning to pass time in a meaningless but delightful way.

Can't do that at Asolare...except meaningless.. Sorry. That's my opinion I guess.