Help picking an island
 

Looking for help picking a Caribbean island for my next vacation. Right now I'm leaning towards Barbados but looking to see if something else might catch my eye.

Looking for an Island with non all inclusive resorts on the beach and the ability to walk to restaurants, nightlife, etc.

Some places we've crossed of the list as we've been to them before: Jamaica, Mexico, St Martin, Dominican Republic, Turks and Caicos, Aruba, Bonaire, Curaçao, Puerto Rico

When I pick the island i'll pay for the resort using points but maybe looking for an island cheaper than Barbados for restaurants, bars, shacks, street food.