EWR to St Kitts
 

What is the best way to fly from Newark to St Kitts? Booking the entire route via one carrier? Or booking into St. Martin or San Juan and taking Liat or Winair from there?

I believe that most people book direct. Try American Airlines, as I know they fly directly into St. Kitts.

I agree with Statia. American has a flight that leaves from EWR around 7:00AM and connects to the American Eagle flight that leave SJU for SKB around 1:30PM. You'll be on-island sipping a pina colada on the beach before 3:00PM. Any other way just wastes valuable beach time.

Would you believe that I live only 9 miles away and it takes me longer than that to get there on WinAir? Go figure.

Statia, that doesn't surprise me one bit. It's difficult to do any "day" island hopping by plane from the island where I have a home too. It's part of the price we pay to live in paradise.