Best Quiet Peacfull Island to Rent a Vacation Home?
 

Just wanted to post a "survey question" as we have been to a few islands but wanting to see if we have missed a great Island among the many... we enjoy relaxation, snorkeling, great views, safety and love to explore, so :
* Which USVI or BVI Island would you vote for best Holiday Vacation Home Rental Destination and why?
Appreciate your feedback everyone!

Virgin Gorda - best combination of each of your outlined criteria particularly quiet. I would add - quaint to the list. Its a beautiful island.

ST John, USVI. Stunningly beautiful. Great beaches, restaurants, hiking and vacation rentals.

Hard to go wrong here.

I'm no expert but seems like St John fits your wish list.

Thanks all for your feedback!