Canada Forums

Post New Topic

Recent Activity

  • Announcement:
  • Come explore the new Fodor’s Forum
    by ibobi Fodor's Editor | Posted on Dec 4, 17 at 08:03 PM
View all Canada activity »
  1. 1 http://www.sexual4facts.com/edge-test-booster/
  2. 2 Nova Scotia, New Brunswick, and PEI in 7 Days
  3. 3 East Cost Road trip from Toronto to NB, PEI, NS in 9 days
  4. 4 Is it possible to drive to Nunavut?
  5. 5 Car rental Montreal airport - anyone use Ace Rent a Car or NU Car Rental?
  6. 6 Montreal for new Years
  7. 7 Trip Report BrITISH COLUMBIA IN 4 DAYS
  8. 8 2018 Road Trip to Alaska
  9. 9 Romantic restaurant in Toronto
  10. 10 Toronto - here we come!
  11. 11 Christmas in Quebec City
  12. 12 How long to drive from Vancouver to Jasper to Banff to calgary
  13. 13 Montreal,Quebec city and St Lawrence river
  14. 14 Trip Report Two weeks in Nova Scotia
  15. 15 Canadian Rockies Timing for Summer 2018
  16. 16 Montreal for New Years
  17. 17 Babymoon Destination
  18. 18 Neighbourhoods recommendation in Vancouver, BC
  19. 19 Music and Scenery in Mova Scotia
  20. 20 Trip Report My Family Travle Vlog
  21. 21 Vancouver Marriott Pinnacle versus Delta Hotels by Marriott
  22. 22 Ottawa in December
  23. 23 Canadian Rockies in late June, 2018
  24. 24 Quebec City Cozy Pubs
  25. 25 Quebec City/Montreal for Christmas
View next 25 » Back to the top

Travelling from NYC to Montreal

Jump to last reply

Hi all,

I am travelling to Montreal from NYC along with my family of 4.
I haven't booked the tickets yet. I am confused between selecting Amtrak Train, Greyhound bus or Trailways bus.

Kindly suggest which one among these options to select. Amtrak takes 11 hours to reach. Greyhound, being a bus, that means having no space to get up and roam around takes around 9 hours. No idea about the Trailways.

Thanking you in advance.

  • Report Abuse

    Hi rahulteck,

    I often do the journey between NYC and Montreal and have tried most of the means between the two. The least painful way from NYC to Montreal is to fly. However, that can be pricey, especially for 4.

    Train Negative: The train is an unusually long way to get from NYC to Montreal. Crossing the border (agents come in and process everyone one by one at a border town) and then getting from the border to Montreal's Central Station can seem like it takes an eternity.

    Trailways or Greyhound negative: They've really improved the efficiency at the border although occasionally (especially around holidays) there can be a line-up of buses, so the border crossing can also take a while. Keep in mind, the Greyhound bus schedule is sometimes only wishful thinking due to traffice in New York City; once I spent 2 hours in the Lincoln Tunnel alone.

    Of the two choices, I tend to pick the train. Yes it's long but for the price I paid two weeks ago($68!), I was willing to suffer a bit! Besides, parts of the ride are absolutely gorgeous; you can move around as you say (I sometimes sit and read in the cafe car) and the whole experience can be kind of social. You're not stuck in your seat like in a bus (which is less pretty, sticking to highway routes), there's a bit more legroom and I like that there are more bathrooms on the bus if nature calls. I find that accepting beforehand that it's going to be a long trip going in makes it bearable.

    Another option I've done sometimes is I've taken the bus as far as Albany, spent the night in downtown Albany and then taken the train (there are 11 trains daily from Albany-NYC) from Albany-Rensselaer to New York City (or DC), which avoids the NY area traffic. I find this a nice option as far as wear-and-tear is concerned, as it divides the trip into bite-size pieces. Yes, it will mean you'll have to shell out money for a night in Albany-- however, you could make it an interesting, educational stop by visiting some of that city's sights while there (such as the Capitol, Lark Street, etc...).

    Best wishes, Daniel

1 Reply |Back to top

Sign in to comment.

Advertisement