Toorhpaste in China?
Would you use the toothpaste in the hotels in China? I was given toothpaste/brush on an Air China flight too.
Actually I'm confused on this subject, could some countries be making toothpaste with ingredients from China and how can you tell? |
I always use my own. Not because of danger, but I hate their taste. And to me, a toothbrush is a very personal item. Also use my own.
[It's kind of interesting that one may be staying at the crappiest dumpy hotel in China with bugs and everything, but they'll have toothbrush/paste and slippers. These are things that Americans carry when traveling, but not Chinese.] Anyways, back to the toothpaste issue. You're talking about the diethylene glycol. It's not a matter of where the ingredients come from. DEG can kill you wherever they're made. It's that it shouldn't be in toothpaste, period. |
Hi Shanghainese,
Unfortunately it's not just the toothpaste supplied IN China, but 'pirated' big brands such as Colgate that contain the deadly diethylene glycol - I read about a warning in Canada last week, where the pirated Colgate was further disguised by being "Made in South Africa". Must admit I checked my stock in the bathroom, and was rather suprised it was "Made in Thailand" - am doing a bit more checking on this. Yesterday, the contaminated Chinese toothpaste was found in several stores in Boston, more details in the Boston Globe's article at http://www.boston.com/news/globe/cit...inated_to.html Jackie |
Thanks, rkkwan and Jackie!
|
I can't add to the larger issue of this thread, but I found it very interesting that the topic was covered by CCTV International Channel (the only English-language CCTV channel, and a prime place for propaganda as would be expected).
They were quick to say that the government is putting in rules to address the situation. Then they had a piece on how DEG is not in that many brands of toothpaste and that anyway, the toxin really isn't that bad for you. They ended the coverage by interviewing a Frenchman on the street, who claimed he will always use the local toothpaste: he's been living in China for 4 years and has never had a problem, lack of memory or anything (I guess addressing possible symptoms of toxin poisoning?). It was definitely a bizarre reporting piece, at least from my Western perspective! ;) |
I love CCTV, but only as a humorous diversion rather than as a primary news source.
I lived in China for 6 years, using Chinese toothpaste for at least 4 of them. In all that time, I can't recall having any symptoms related to memory loss :p |
Actually, the CCTV news can be useful. If it mentions something, then it must be <b>really</b> bad. Just to have a toothpaste story means hundreds if not thousands have been made sick.
You just have to "interpret" the story correctly. |
Yes, I agree with you both, baaj and rkkwan - CCTV is both a humorous diversion and an interesting read into the "mind" of the government.
The week I arrived was the 10-year anniversary of the HK handover, and my sensitive lefty sensibilities couldn't handle all the talk of the "return to the motherland" - so I watched the ceremonies on a Chinese language channel instead, so that I wouldn't have to know what they were saying! (My hotel only provides CCTV, no cable channels.) Now that I've become a bit more adjusted, I enjoy watching the channel to hear that perspective. Last night there was a round table discussion on the DPRK (aka North Korea). Unfortunately I was too sleepy to listen closely! |
A new idea for good gifts for Chinese, genuine American toothpaste! :-) I told one Chinese friend I am bringing toothpaste. He said to not do that, thinking perhaps it was a put-down of China. I said, "No, I think too much of your family for you to use toxic chemicals." He reconsidered, and approved the gift.
|
All times are GMT -8. The time now is 07:21 PM. |