Fodor's Travel Talk Forums

Fodor's Travel Talk Forums (https://www.fodors.com/community/)
-   Asia (https://www.fodors.com/community/asia/)
-   -   Japan train reservations (https://www.fodors.com/community/asia/japan-train-reservations-476330/)

dgruzew Sep 24th, 2004 07:36 AM

Japan train reservations
 
Hi,

we are leaving for japan in about 2 weeks and we need some help figuring out how to get around

I need to make the following train trips and I need to figure out how and when to book tickets and reservations. I will not be buyting a rail pass beacuse I don't think it is cost effiecnt

-Round trip tickets from toyko to hakone area
(hakone free pass?)
-One way from Toyko to Kyoto (shinkensen)
-Round trip from Kyoto to himeji castle
-round trip from Kyoto to Nara
-One way from Kyoto to Kansai (KIX) airport

I need to know when and where to make reservations if required - I don't want to stand on any of the train rides longer than 30 minutes


emd Sep 24th, 2004 08:04 AM

HI dgruzew. I'm sure you will get seasoned help. I've monitored questions like this and have seen many people make reference to using the www.hyperdia.com site for that kind of specific train info. It is apparently a trick to read the train schedules on that site, but if you search on here for hyperdia and go through the postings (it's not that many) you'll see that mrwunrfl and maybe others posted instructions on how to access and interpret the hyperdia site info.
I have been searching myself on the Hakone Free pass, and there have been posts in last few days on getting it at Shinjuku station, which seems to be the popular place to get it. But I have also found sites and heard from posters on here saying you can buy it at other stations, including Machida and Odwara right in Hakone. I found these sites helpful:
www.japan-guide.com/e/e5206.html
(which discusses how you can go to Hakone either on the Odakyu line, getting the free pass at Shinjuku when you deaprt, or by Shinkansen, getting free pass at Odawara station when you get off in Hakone area)
also: www.japan-guide.com/e/e2358_008.html
and: http://www.odakyu-group.co.jp/englis.../hakone_01.htm

emd Sep 24th, 2004 09:02 AM

I have alot of these transportation posts printed out and found some you might want to review. One by KimJapan and others that desribes the train reservation process (which says seats can apparently only be reserved inside Japan) and the types of train cars available, etc. Title of the post is: Tours in Japan - are there any?, and last post made was on 5/23/04. So if you search for KimJapan's posts, it will come up.
Some of mrwunrfl's hints on using hyperdia are in the post "transportation to/from Takayama" last post on that one was on 7/1/04; search for mrwunrfl and you'll see it.
Also other info in this post: Help Getting Around Japan, last post was on 7/2/04 (mrwunrfl, Florence, and I are on that one, so you can search for our posts and you'll find it)

dgruzew Sep 24th, 2004 09:13 AM

emd - you are so helpful - thank you so much

KimJapan Sep 24th, 2004 02:49 PM

Before deciding that a rail pass isn't cost effectvive, you might want to check your routings on hyperdia.com (they have english). Tokyo to Kyoto is 13,520 (one way); Kyoto to Himeji is 5,130 each way (a little less if don't use the shinkansen); Kyoto to Nara about 1,000 each way (loads of trains, varying prices); Kyoto to Kansai airport 3,490. An ordinary JR pass for one week is 28,300 yen.

With only the trips you have here, you'll spend the equivalent of the pass. With the pass, seat reservations can be made at any station in the same line as ticket sales.

Without the pass, you'll need to buy individual tickets. No problem at all...you can buy them from machines in many stations, but you may have a little trouble figuring out the fares and machines without reading Japanese. Tickets can also be bought at the ticket counter in advance or just before you go.

In either case, seat reservations should be made as soon as possible if you want non-smoking reserved seats, as they almosts always sell out of the non-smoking seats. If you can't get a reserved seat, there are also cars that have no reserved seats at all and you can try your luck for a seat in them. If your schedule is flexible, and there were no seats on your train of choice, you could select another train and try for seats on that one. The station staff is generally pretty helpful.

Alternatively, you can buy train tickets from travel agents. You can find travel agents all over the place. Just look for a shop with lots of Disney and Hawaii brochures out front.


emd1 Sep 24th, 2004 02:56 PM

dgruzew, of all the issues I have been researching for our trip, Japan transportation is the biggest challenge. You will see from one of those posts that hyperdia is a bit quirky. Let me know what you learn, as I have some of the same routes to deal with (Kyoto to Himeji, Kyoto to Nara) and am not yet sure a rail pass is the best for what I am doing over 14 days either.
I am getting excited for you, after following your recent posts. I hope others chime in on your post here. Also, I find the forum on www.japan-guide.com very helpful w/specific questions like this.

mrwunrfl Sep 24th, 2004 04:25 PM


It's a no-brainer: you should buy a pass. As the research that KimJapan did for you shows, the cost of the 7-day pass is less than the cost of individually purchased reserved seat tickets. If you are definitely going to make those trips, then it is cost effective. If there is a chance that you might decide to skip going to Himeji, then you would be better off buying tickets (but I think it was a must-see for you, if I recall correctly).

I had no trouble getting non-smoking reserved seats in May. You can get them in advance.

Get the pass activated on October 13th and you can use it that day in Tokyo. You can then use it to get to Odawara for your day visit to Hakone. At Hakone, get the Hakone Free Pass to go around the tourist route. Return to Odawara to take the shinkansen to Shinagawa and then the JR Yamanote Line (both using your JR Pass) and subway to Roppongi.

At Odawara, get your reserved seats for your trip the next day to Kyoto. You could also get your seats for the Himeji, Nara, and KIX trips at that time (or get all of your reserved seats when you activate your pass). It is really easy and the thing is that the reserved seats are free. Since you got them with your JR Pass if you miss a train then just throw the reserved seat ticket away and get a new one for the next train.

If you decide to buy tickets, then you will need to find out what the change/refund policy is for the reserved seats. I don't know what that policy is because, to me, reserved seats are free with my JR Pass.

dgruzew Sep 25th, 2004 09:23 AM

Great - thanks for the advice!!!!
I guess I will buy a pass !!!

Where should I buy it? the JTB office here wants 286 bucks for it? that it not the correct exchange rate - I should pay about 260 usd ? where can I buy one?
A couple other questions how do you activate the pass??

And also luggage - we will have backpacks and one large suitcase - should I send it to kyoto with a luggage service or carry it the train. If I send it - then how do I do so

Thanks - you guys are great

JoyceL Sep 25th, 2004 10:31 AM

The Hyperdia site shows 2 fees for each ticket: a "Fare", and a "Charge". The Charge is almost as much as the Fare. Can anyone explain the difference between these fees? Is the Charge fee always required?

emd Sep 25th, 2004 11:45 AM

Someone else can fill you in on the pass (I am not to that stage of planning yet), but I have printed several posts that say that you can have your hotel in Tokyo (or whereever) arrange to send your luggage to your desitnation for a reasonable fee (I think mrwunrfl or Kim said like $20-24 per bag). Kim said it takes overnight to get the bags to the next hotel. That is what I am doing when we go from Yokohama to Kyoto, since we are stopping for a night or two in Hakone and even though we are both traveling w/only one 21" roll-on and a day pack, I don't want to be hauling it all over those busses and trains in the Hakone area. We will just travel w/day packs to Hakone and send the luggage to Kyoto. You can see the limited space on the trains for luggage on mrwunrfl's pictures at www.billk.org There has been alot of discussion about the limited luggage space on the trains- the buzz seems to be that if you have a small roll-on (like 21" or less) then you can perhaps fit it in the small space afforded at the back of the train car (again, see the pics), if that is available. Not much will fit in the limited overhead space; from the pics it looks like a daypack might fit. If you are lucky and have an empty seat next to you then you can put your luggage there. I am just relaying what I have read on here...

emd Sep 25th, 2004 12:19 PM

Actually, now that I looked again, there is more overhead space than I recalled on those pictures, and a note by mrwunrfl that thee shinkansen overhead storage is more accomodating than the one in the picture. But I still don't wnat to have to transfer my luggage from train to bus, etc. and we will be going straight from the train station at Odawara to the Yunessun resort, and I sure don't want to drag my luggage there. Are you stopping in Hakone for the day? I guess you may not want to be hauling those backpacks and suitcase around Hakone.

dgruzew Sep 25th, 2004 12:56 PM

emd - we decided do a round trip day trip (no bags at all) to hakone from tokyo - so it won't be problem. I am going email my hotel to see if they transfer bags

KimJapan Sep 25th, 2004 02:54 PM

The train ticket price is a bit hard to understand. There is the basic fare, like for Kanazawa to Osaka, it's 4,620 yen. You can pay only this fare if you use the slowest, stop at every stop, local trains - it would take all day to make the 3 hour trip though. The other amount of money, or the charge, is for the better, faster train with fewer stops and getting you there faster. From Kanazawa to Osaka, the charge is 2,820 yen. The total price you pay for riding that train is 7,440 yen.
If you don't need a seat reservation, it's 510 less. For such a small amount of money, I always buy the seat reservation and save myself the hassle of lining up for non-reserved seats 1/2 hour before the train comes (and then not even getting a seat sometimes).


mrwunrfl Sep 26th, 2004 06:04 PM


I use a backpack that is 12 inches deep when it is full, 17 inches wide when bulging, and 26 inches tall from the bottom of the wheels to the top of the top handle. There is a smaller backpack, 6 inches deep, that zips onto the back of it. When the small backpack is unzipped, the big pack fits in the overhead on the shinkansen and on an airplane, and it fits in the lockers at the JR stations.

All about the JR Pass:
http://www.japanrailpass.net/eng/en05.html

dgruzew Sep 27th, 2004 06:34 PM

I will have a camera bag , backpack and we will have a decent size suitcase approx 12deep 20wide 32high. What is the best way to carry this? Should I ship luggage? This might work fine for my Tokyo to Kyoto Leg - but I also need to take a train (with my baggage) to KIX from Kyoto?

any ideas? will my suitcase really not fit on the trains?

KimJapan Sep 27th, 2004 06:42 PM

The train from Kyoto to Kansai airport (Haruka) has a baggage compartment at the end of each car that is almost always empty (because everyone ships their luggage ahead) so you'll be fine there. A suitcase of that size may fit behind the end row of seats in each car too. I'd imagine your biggest trouble might be getting it up and down the stairs everywhere. Most stations have up escalators, but down escalators are more rare. Elevators are for disabled use in most stations, and require calling an attendant to use them.

Florence Sep 27th, 2004 11:05 PM

Bonjour KimJapan,

The platform for train from Kyoto to Kansai airport (Haruka) is on the ground floor in Kyoto (no stairs involved) and there are escalators and elevators in the Kansai station.

KimJapan Sep 28th, 2004 12:14 AM

Yes...the airport train isn't trouble. I wasn't clear in my post. It's other stations and trains that might be probematic. Like to enter Osaka station, you need to go down 3 or 4 steps to get in, or else walk around the side...not marked either...to get into the station. the to get to the platforms there are escalators, but only up. In Kanazawa, there are up escalators, but no down. What I meant to convey was that it is more the norm for train stations to be a challenge to carry baggage through than for it to be easy like the Kansai airport Haruka line's stations.

Even with more and more stations becoming compliant with barrier free access, that access is often itself a challenge, involving calling attendants to unlock the elevator and operate it for you, or not having an elevator or escalator at all but having a stair-climbing wheelchair lift, again involving calling the attendant to come unlock and operate it. These things aren't for general passenger use, baggage or not.

I've been through many stations with backpacks, suitcases on wheels, child in a stroller...and learned quickly, many years ago, to minimize what I needed to carry, both because of the stairs and distance to the tracks, and also because of the crowds making it difficult to even pull a suitcase on wheels behind me.

The baggage delivery services are so efficient and affordable that unless we drive ourselves, we always send our bags ahead. That may not be feasible for travellers in the middle of a trip who need everything in their bags, though...so packing lightly and anticipating having to carry it up and down stairs might be a good idea.

albaaust Oct 5th, 2004 05:52 PM

Hi just arrived after spending a month travelling around Japan. It was fantastic!! We used a JR railpass for two weeks. I organised our itinerary based around the hyperedia site beforehand and printed off schedules etc which turned out to be a good move. A question regarding your luggage? Do you have health problems carrying the luggage? I ask this because we had two large suitcases admittedly with wheels but we took our luggage with us all the time. There is a small amount of space at the end of each carriage and stored our cases there. We went to Osaka for one day and stored our luggage for the day for about 800yen- every major train station has what they call coin lockers so in response to luggage and what to do for the day while you sight see that is an option. By the way I would thoroughly recommend visiting Nara! Any other queries I will be happy to respond to.

emd Oct 5th, 2004 06:06 PM

albaaust: Your trip sounds great. I have a question about hyperdia. You found it to be reliable then, right? Sometimes their routings seem so convoluted, and then when I put in a time a half hour later I can get a much better routing. Because of this, and because I do not want to box us into taking trains at certain times before we go and having to print out all the options, I am thinking I am going to bite the bullet and take a laptop (a very thin one and the most light weight one I can buy) so that I will have it to check train schedules on hyperdia as we want to go and as our plans change. Our hotels have high speend internet access so I think this will give us maximum flexibility, although I hate the thought of taking a laptop.

albaaust Oct 5th, 2004 06:32 PM

Hyperedia was accurate to the exact time every time! Tell me what you did when you used it? At times we went to out of the way places and there were a couple of transfer times I thought would be dodgy eg. 3 minutes but it worked beautifully. What I did is I also printed off the timetable of stations from each destination so I knew exactly where we should be and what time we should be there. However, it wasn't really needed as on most shinkansen they do have a print out (in English) of each station just as we were about to arrive. The train to Kanasawa if my memory is correct didn't.

albaaust Oct 5th, 2004 06:41 PM

Sorry emd just reread what you wrote-its early morning where I am so still getting my head together! Firstly, depending on where you are going from there might be a faster train going to where you want to go to at a later time! For us it was only when we were travelling from Kyushu that there was more than a 15 minutes gap between trains. Don't forget that you cannot use a Nozumi with a JR pass- for us it wasn't a problem.

albaaust Oct 5th, 2004 06:51 PM

Another thought emd. We stayed in business hotels which had free computer access. That meant that we could keep up to date at home and if we wanted access to other sites. I also used an internet service in Kyoto (very near the JR station) which charged 280yen for half an hour. I don't know about the cost of printing pages but you might find that taking a laptop is unnecessary.

mrwunrfl Oct 5th, 2004 06:52 PM

albaaust, glad to hear you had a great trip. I would love to read your trip report. In particular, did you end up staying at the Tour Club in Kyoto?

emd, you can leave your laptop at home. Florence mentioned once that there is a location in Tokyo where you can get a JR timetable in English. She also mentioned a book ("Japan by Rail" ? or something like that) that has schedule info in it. You could also check with JNTO (now, in Jan, Feb) to see if they have printed timetables (they used to). Hyperdia does give some convoluted itineraries. If you give me an example of a trip that is giving you trouble, then I can help you work out how to get the info you need. Basically, you use hyperdia to first identify the JR lines that serve your destination then the quickest trains (Hikari, Kodama, Limited Expresses, locals) and get the daily schedule for each.

In addition to the internet access where you are staying, you can also use internet cafes. The schedules are posted at the JR stations, of course, and I got in the habit of getting an outbound seat reservation on arrival in a city.

OTOH, BigFeat did use a portable device for destination guide info and stuff. With your methodical approach and thorough collection of information, I expect that you probably have it well organized. The tradeoff might be deciding which way is better for travelling light: carry the hardcopy printouts or lug a laptop. And maybe you can watch DVDs on it on the plane and/or he and you can play games. I saw a nice little laptop at the Newington Costco the other day. But that would be a sledgehammer solution to the problem of cracking the walnut of JR schedules.

mrwunrfl Oct 5th, 2004 07:01 PM


Please insert a winky-smiley after "lug a laptop" above. ;)

albaaust Oct 5th, 2004 07:10 PM

Hi again after all that research about the Tour Club we couldn't get a booking! However, I used a cheap hotel site to book the Dai Ni Tower Hotel in Kyoto. It cost about 120AUD a night perfect for our needs. It is about 5 minutes from the JR station and the major bus stops. There is also a number of shops, restaurants connected to the railway station so as I said it turned out fine. We had most of our meals in the restaurant area which was in the subway section of the station.The hotel itself was OK-usual cubicle bathroom and toilet, TV and only just enough room to store our cases.By the way was it you who were keen about the plasma TVs in the Tour Club? If so, it is a red herring -all the TV channels are in Japanese.You might get lucky and there might be an English dubbing service for one of the TV channels (can't remember the name..NKK??) but anyway, you will have to content yourself with watching baseball, Sumo wresting which has just started or the occasional movie!

mrwunrfl Oct 5th, 2004 07:22 PM


Sumo, hai! Now? Where? I thought that the Kyushu Bassho didn't start until November in Fukuoka. Maybe it is local sumo for determining who goes to the Grand Sumo?

albaaust Oct 5th, 2004 07:31 PM

You could be right..as I said everything was in Japanese. I read some where (Lonely Planet?) that you can go and watch the Sumo wrestling live but from what I have seen on television it is a very quick fight! Having said that it was all part of immersing oneself in the culture!

emd Oct 5th, 2004 07:48 PM

albaaust: Get some sleep and then give us a good juicy trip report! This board has been asleep for days, we need the fresh blood. And dgruzew is getting ready to leave soon, so he needs your trip report to get him really revved up too.

mrwunrfl: Ok, if you think it is doable, I will be happy not to lug a laptop. I never travel w/one so why start now unless it is needed (and I can take the portable DVD player w/an extra battery for the flights) I will dig out that posting by Florence- I recall it and I remember there was some lively discussion on whether you really could get the English timetables or not, but if the outcome was that you can, by golly I will track the place down in Tokyo and I'll get the book too. I'll check w/JNTO too- I am thinking of dropping by there while I am in NY later this wk.


albaaust Oct 5th, 2004 07:55 PM

Just realised that I was given a hard copy in English of the JR timetable. I did not use it(because I already had my own copy of the itinerary). I think someone from a JR Ticket office gave me one so I believe they are easy to get!
As for my report..I do feel that I should write something in detail as I got a lot of help from people like you from this site! What do you think I should focus on?

mrwunrfl Oct 5th, 2004 07:59 PM


emd is right, albaaust, we want to hear all about it. You can start at the beginning. Was it Qantas from Perth or JAL from Sydney, or what?

HappyTraveling Oct 6th, 2004 08:43 AM

I'll be traveling on the train from Tokyo to Kyoto on Nov 21, which is supposedly a very popular time in Kyoto because of the momiji (autumn leaves).

I've just checked the website to reserve seats and it appears that I am only allowed to make the reservation 1 month prior to travel, applicable to JR pass holders.

However, those purchasing single tickets can make a reservation 2 months before travel.

Does anyone know if this will be a problem for me to wait until the 1 month limit? Is there a way around it? Is it possible to make the seat reservation as non-JR Pass holder?

HELP! I have my parents traveling with me, so standing for 3 hours or so is not very desirable for them.

Any tip is much appreciated!

mrwunrfl Oct 6th, 2004 06:35 PM


Don't worry, you'll be fine. You will enjoy the autumn colors of the momiji (maple) leaves.

HappyTraveling Nov 6th, 2004 04:28 AM

Hi again!

I'm still confused with the pricing of the tickets.
I will be traveling with the Japan Rail Pass. Does that include the ticket and the seat reservation? or does the seat reservation come in addition?

HELP!

mrwunrfl Nov 6th, 2004 05:58 AM


The JR Pass includes seat reservations.

mrwunrfl Nov 6th, 2004 06:01 AM


That is, you don't pay anything more when you get seat reservations.

http://www.japanrailpass.net/eng/en06.html


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 07:47 AM.