Graeter's

Member Reviews

• Beatchick, from Originally from Oakland, CA; have lived in Cincy for 16 yrs.
  11/25/11

  I've never understood the rabid loyalty to Graeter's when Aglamesi's in Oakley is so much better and more authentically old fashioned. Except for when they have a specialty seasonal ice cream (pumpkin comes to mind), I see no reason to make a special trek to Graeter's; besides, they don't even use real whipped cream on their sundaes. In comparison, a trip to Aglamesi's is a special treat especially when you choose to dine in the Belle Epoque atmosphere.

  Ratings details: Food: 5 | Atmosphere: 5 | Service: 5 | Value: 5
• frankhamil, from Lexington, KY
  12/18/07

  I have eaten ice cream all over the world, including the homemade ice creams of the purported two ice cream capitals: New York City and Philadelphia. In my opinion, no one has better ice cream than Graeter's. Glad they've spread out to other cities. I remember when the only place outside Cincinnati where you could find Graeter's was at Bloomingdales in NYC.
  
  My personal favorites are: seasonal flavors: strawberry chip and pumpkin pie with their homemade whipped cream.
  Favorite treat: Turtle Sundae in waffle bowl.
  
  Frank Hamilton

  Ratings details: Food: 5 | Atmosphere: 4 | Service: 4 | Value: 5