Fodor's Expert Review Old Mill Restaurant

$$$ Old Forge and Eagle Bay American

Editor's Note: This location is no longer in operation.

This popular restaurant and bar is housed in a converted mill, complete with a huge waterwheel. It's a place seasonal residents come back to, and that's probably because the restaurant does Adirondack fare—hearty, warming food in large portions—very, very well. The beef and barley stew or the cheddar cheese soup are consistent favorites. And while you may have a wait since reservations aren't accepted, the fare and comfortable surroundings will make up for it.

American Lunch Dinner Dessert $$$

Quick Facts

2888 state
Old Forge, New York  13420, USA

315-369-3662

Restaurant Details:
Rate Includes: Closed Nov.–late Dec. and mid-Mar.–Apr. No lunch., Credit cards accepted, Reservations not accepted

What’s Nearby

Related Forum Posts