Long Island Restaurants

We’ve compiled the best of the best in Long Island - browse our top choices for Restaurants during your stay.

Sort by: 6 Recommendations {{numTotalPoiResults}} {{ (numTotalPoiResults===1)?'Recommendation':'Recommendations' }} 0 Recommendations
CLEAR ALL Area Search CLEAR ALL
Loading...
  • 1. Grana Trattoria Antica

    $$

    Not only are the wood-fired pizza and handmade pasta dishes here delicious, they are also made with organic stone-ground flour using local, seasonal produce, handmade mozzarella, and artisanal meats. Try the fig, caramelized onion, and Gorgonzola pizza or the mushroom pasta with locally sourced porcinis. For a splurge, go for the $65 2-lb wood-fired T-bone, medium rare.

    1556 Main Rd., Jamesport, New York, 11947, USA
    631-779–2844
  • 2. Tweeds Restaurant & Buffalo Bar

    $$$$

    Housed in the old John J. Sullivan hotel on Main Street, this homey restaurant harks back to the Victorian era and exudes masses of charm—stained glass, chandeliers in old oil-burning style, an 1893 mahogany and marble bar made for the Chicago Exposition, a rich mantled fireplace, and the head of the last buffalo shot by Teddy Roosevelt. Buffalo (bison) meat is on the menu, lower in fat and higher in protein than beef and it tastes pretty much the same, only "beefier." If you don't want to splurge on the $44 cowboy steak, go for the $20 buffalo burger. An organic beef burger is also available. You may have guessed that meat is king here, but vegetarians are not entirely forgotten—try the roast portobello mushroom with homemade ricotta. Tweeds also boasts the biggest selection of bourbons.

    17 E. Main St., Aquebogue, New York, 11901, USA
    631-237–8120
  • 3. Digger"s Ale N' Eats

    $$

    In a region popular for seafood, this place is all about the meat. The most popular dish here is a 24-oz bone-in ribeye, and you can also get handcrafted pub standards such as shepherd's pie and fish-and-chips. A cool local hangout spot, the pub hosts live music on Friday and Saturday and has a selection of more than 100 beers. A children's menu is available and brunch is served every Sunday.

    58 W. Main St., Riverhead, New York, 11901, USA
    631-369–3200

    Restaurant Details

    Rate Includes: Credit cards accepted
  • 4. Modern Snack Bar

    $$

    Anyone who has driven Main Road in Aqueboque at night, driving back from the wineries or heading home from Greenport, has most definitely noticed the Las Vegas–like sign illuminating this otherwise sleepy strip. At this unpretentious family-owned café, beloved by locals and out-of-towners alike, you'll find comfort food at its best, including Long Island duck, roast loin of pork with sauerkraut, softshell crabs, and home-baked strawberry-rhubarb and lemon-meringue pies. They do take-out too.

    628 Main Rd., Aquebogue, New York, 11931, USA
    631-722–3655

    Restaurant Details

    Rate Includes: Closed Mon. and mid-Dec.–early Apr., Credit cards accepted, Reservations not accepted
  • 5. Jamesport Country Kitchen

    $$
    Closed Permanently

    The food outshines the surroundings at this eatery, which looks like a simple, wood-shingled country store. While the interior is reminicent of your sweet grandmother's home, the menu is contemporary, and dishes feature local ingredients such as fresh seafood and Long Island duck. The place is open year-round, and its menu changes with the season. The ever-changing wine list also has a local focus.

    1601 Main Rd., Jamesport, New York, 11947, USA
    631-722–3537

    Restaurant Details

    Rate Includes: Closed Tues., Credit cards accepted
  • Recommended Fodor’s Video

  • 6. Meetinghouse Creek Inn

    $$$
    Closed Permanently

    The seafood at this waterside restaurant, 4 miles east of Riverhead, is a big draw—it all comes from local sources—but the kitchen also turns out good steaks and pasta dishes, and in addition to the regular menu there's a daily $23 prix-fixe dinner. There's a patio for open-air dining, or you can enjoy a beverage at the outdoor tiki bar. If you're arriving by boat, docking is fee. Reservations are suggested.

    177 Meeting House Creek Rd., Aquebogue, New York, 11931, USA
    631-722–4220

    Restaurant Details

    Rate Includes: Credit cards accepted

No Restaurants Results

Please try a broader search, or expore these popular suggestions:

There are no results for {{ strDestName}} Restaurants in the searched map area with the above filters. Please try a different area on the map, or broaden your search with these popular suggestions:

Recommended Fodor’s Video