Sign Up
Newsletter Signup
Free Fodor's Newsletter

Subscribe today for weekly travel inspiration, tips, and special offers.

Passport: Your weekly travel wrap-up
Today's Departure: Your daily dose of travel inspiration

Long Island Hotels

The American Hotel

  • 45 Main St. Map It
  • Sag Harbor


  • On-site restaurant
  • In the center of town, so you don't necessarily need a car


  • Lacking more modern amenities like docking stations and TVs
  • Rooms above bars can suffer from noise
  • Minimum stays may apply in high season

Updated 01/12/2015

Fodor's Review

Victorian elegance defines this hotel dating from 1846, a three-story brick-facade house with a white-pillared porch that looks out onto Main Street. Each guest room has turn-of-the-20th-century antiques and spacious bathrooms with whirpool baths. An on-site restaurant and bar inhabit four intimate, antiques-filled rooms, including a front room with a Steinway piano (and a pianist Wednesday through Sunday in July and August) and a bar room that attracts a sophisticated crowd.

Hotel Information


45 Main St., Sag Harbor, New York, 11963, United States

Map It



Hotel Details:

  • Credit cards accepted
  • 8 rooms
  • Rate includes: Breakfast

Updated 01/12/2015

View Long Island Hotel Rates


Map View

Map of

What's Nearby

  • Restaurants
  • Sights
  • Hotels

See all hotels in Long Island

Add Your Own Review

When did you stay?

Minimum 200 character count

How many stars would you give?







No Thanks

Love To Travel?

Get FREE e-mail communications from Fodor's Travel, covering must-see travel destinations, expert trip planning advice, and travel inspiration to fuel your passion.

How we use your email

Thank You

Now sit back, relax, and check your inbox to start planning your next travel adventure.

Please tell us more about the type of travel you're interested in. Check all that apply.