Long Island Hotels

The American Hotel

  • 45 Main St. Map It
  • Sag Harbor


  • On-site restaurant
  • In the center of town, so you don't necessarily need a car


  • Lacking more modern amenities like docking stations and TVs
  • Rooms above bars can suffer from noise
  • Minimum stays may apply in high season

Published 07/23/2015

Fodor's Review

Victorian elegance defines this hotel dating from 1846, a three-story brick-facade house with a white-pillared porch that looks out onto Main Street. Each guest room has turn-of-the-20th-century antiques and spacious bathrooms with whirpool baths. An on-site restaurant and bar inhabit four intimate, antiques-filled rooms, including a front room with a Steinway piano (and a pianist Wednesday through Sunday in July and August) and a bar room that attracts a sophisticated crowd.

Hotel Information


45 Main St., Sag Harbor, New York, 11963, United States

Map It



Hotel Details:

  • Credit cards accepted
  • 8 rooms
  • Rate includes: Breakfast

Published 07/23/2015

View Long Island Hotel Rates


Map View

Map of

What's Nearby

  • Restaurants
  • Sights
  • Hotels

See all hotels in Long Island

Add Your Own Review

When did you stay?

Minimum 200 character count

How many stars would you give?





No Thanks