Home Destinations USA New York Hamptons and Montauk Hotels Fire Island Hotel & Resort

Fire Island Hotel & Resort Review

Read our Hamptons and Montauk hotel reviews. Or post your own.

Fire Island Hotel & Resort

Address: 25 Cayuga Walk, Ocean Bay Park, Fire Island, NY, 11770 | Map It
Phone: 631/583-8000
Fax: 631/583-9404

Price range: $-$$$$
Location: Fire Island

Write a review

Fodor's Review:

The hotel has water views and is a short walk (100 yards) to the beach. The pool, an uncommon find on Fire Island, is a plus. Rooms have either one double bed, two doubles, or a twin and a double. The suites sleep six. Bathrooms have been updated. There's a three-night minimum on weekends, which includes a $50 voucher for the hotel restaurant. Rates are significantly less expensive on weekdays. The hotel also has a few cabins, studios, and apartments, but these are usually booked up by its time-share members.

Hotel Details: 30 rooms, 4 suites
In-room: no a/c (some).
In-hotel: restaurant, room service, bar, pool, laundry service, no-smoking rooms.
Credit Cards: AE, D, MC, V
Closed: Closed early Oct.-mid-May