Home Destinations USA New York Hamptons and Montauk Hotels Montauk Yacht Club, Resort and Marina

Montauk Yacht Club, Resort and Marina Review

Read our Hamptons and Montauk hotel reviews. Or post your own.

Montauk Yacht Club, Resort and Marina

  • Price range: $$-$$$$
  • Location: Montauk
Write a review | Avg. member rating: 2.4/5

Fodor's Review:

The plush resort on Star Island, in Montauk Harbor, has its own mini-replica of the Montauk Lighthouse as well as a 232-slip marina. Rooms, contemporary and bright, have floor-to-ceiling windows and private terraces. The waterfront villas contain 23 oversize rooms.

  • Hotel Details: 107 rooms
  • In-room: safe, DVD, Wi-Fi.
  • In-hotel: restaurant, room service, tennis courts, bar, children's programs (ages 5 and up), pool, gym, spa, laundry service, Wi-Fi hotspot, no-smoking rooms.
  • Credit Cards: AE, DC, MC, V
  • Closed: Closed Nov.-early Apr.
Find more hotels in Hamptons and Montauk »

Member Reviews and Ratings

Reviewed by mesange from NYC on 10/20/08
The Montauk Yacht Club offers some great deals during the shoulder seasons, especially during weekdays, but you'll need to make some special requests and bring earplugs to get a decent night's sleep. Noise travels through the guest room walls as though they were tissue paper. I'm usually a deep sleeper but I was constantly woken up by the noise of the staff and of guests in other rooms. Since guest rooms are stacked on a two-level structure, you hear the loudly creaking stairs outside your door. And if your room is near a supply closet, you'll hear that door, the staff rummaging and hauling equipment, etc. The hotel is supposedly renovating the rooms and improving the soundproofing but until that happens, be prepared! Ask for a room that's not near the equipment closets, or preferably with empty neighboring rooms.

Member Rating: 2.4
Ratings details: Room: 2.0 Atmosphere: 2.0 Service: 3.0 Value: 3.0
Add your own review

Get Advice From Other Travelers

Visit the Travel Talk forums for help on planning your trip



Get the Fodor's Newsletter

For more travel ideas, tips, and deals, sign up for the Fodor's newsletter here. Read the current issue. Browse previous issues.




Copyright © 2010 Fodor's Travel, a division of Random House, Inc.