Trip IdeasMid-Range Restaurants in Hamptons and Montauk
Read our Hamptons and Montauk restaurant reviews. Or post your own.
- Overview
- Places to Explore
- Sights
- Restaurants
- Hotels
- Entertainment
- Shopping
- Travel Tips
- Features
- Fodor's Choice
- Deals
- Guidebooks
Mid-Range Restaurants in Hamptons and Montauk
| Name | Price/ Cuisine |
Location |
|
Almond
This cozy spot, with a pressed-tin ceiling and loads of wood... Be the first to write a review |
$$-$$$$ French |
Bridgehampton
View on a map |
|
B. Smith's
The world's finest yachts sit at your feet when you're on the... | Reserve Online Be the first to write a review |
$$-$$$ Eclectic |
Sag Harbor
View on a map |
|
Barrister's
Simple but good American fare is the rule here, as are friendly... Be the first to write a review |
$-$$$ American |
Southampton
View on a map |
|
Basilico
The upscale patrons who favor this restaurant in Southampton... Be the first to write a review |
$$-$$$$ Italian |
Southampton
View on a map |
|
Belle's Cafe
Caribbean, Cajun, and creole specialties such as blackened catfish... Be the first to write a review |
$-$$$ Southern |
Westhampton Beach
View on a map |
|
Belle's East
This fancy outpost of Belle's Cafe in Westhampton Beach serves... Be the first to write a review |
$$-$$$$ Southern |
Southampton
View on a map |
|
The Blue Parrot
The killer margaritas complement the intensely flavored Tex-Mex... Write a review | Avg. member rating: 4.4/5 |
$-$$$ Mexican |
East Hampton
View on a map |
|
Chowder Pot Pub
The views of Peconic Bay at this casual seafood spot are best... Be the first to write a review |
$$-$$$ Seafood |
Greenport
View on a map |
|
Claudio's Clam Bar/Claudio's Restaurant/Crabby Jerry's
These three restaurants share a 2½-acre waterfront property... Write a review | Avg. member rating: 2.8/5 |
$$ Seafood |
Greenport
View on a map |
|
Coeur des Vignes
The name of this family-run restaurant in Long Island's wine... Be the first to write a review |
$$-$$$ French |
Southold
View on a map |
|
Conca D'oro
Large portions, down-home cooking, and reasonable prices make... Be the first to write a review |
$-$$ Italian |
Sag Harbor
View on a map |
|
Dave's Grill
Unpretentious yet stylish, Dave's is at the Montauk fishing docks... Be the first to write a review |
$$-$$$ Contemporary |
Montauk
View on a map |
|
Digger O'Dells
In addition to such pub standards as shepherd's pie, fish-and-chips... Be the first to write a review |
$-$$ Irish |
Riverhead
View on a map |
|
The Dock
Seafaring-related antiques festoon the rustic wood walls and... Write a review | Avg. member rating: 2.4/5 |
$-$$ American |
Montauk
View on a map |
|
Dockers
People stop in at this casual, lively waterfront restaurant on... Be the first to write a review |
$$-$$$$ Seafood |
Quogue
View on a map |
|
Dockside Bar & Grill
On the first warm day of the season, locals flock to the umbrella-shaded... Be the first to write a review |
$-$$ Seafood |
Sag Harbor
View on a map |
|
The Dory
At this relaxed spot, seafood dishes are served on a scenic deck... Be the first to write a review |
$-$$ Seafood |
Shelter Island
View on a map |
|
Driver's Seat
The dining room, whose huge stone fireplace is often ablaze in... Be the first to write a review |
$-$$$ American |
Southampton
View on a map |
|
East by Northeast
Earth tones and Asian accents decorate this sophisticated and... Be the first to write a review |
$$-$$$$ Contemporary |
Montauk
View on a map |
|
East Hampton Point
You can watch the sun go down over Three Mile Harbor through... Be the first to write a review |
$$-$$$$ Contemporary |
East Hampton
View on a map |
|
Estia
The talented chef uses only the finest organic ingredients to... Be the first to write a review |
$-$$$ American |
Amagansett
View on a map |
|
Estia's Little Kitchen
A mile outside Sag Harbor center, this roadside restaurant serves... Be the first to write a review |
$-$$$ Contemporary |
Sag Harbor
View on a map |
|
The Farmhouse
The dining room is done up like a country farmhouse, with an... Be the first to write a review |
$$-$$$ French |
East Hampton
View on a map |
The Frisky Oyster 
This sophisticated, modern restaurant is a little piece of Manhattan... Write a review | Avg. member rating: 4.8/5 |
$$-$$$ Contemporary |
Greenport
View on a map |
|
George Martin
The new American takes on steak and seafood, the regional specialties... Be the first to write a review |
$$-$$$$ American |
Southampton
View on a map |
|
Gianni's
The best brick-oven pizza and focaccia sandwiches in Montauk... Be the first to write a review |
¢-$$ Pizza |
Montauk
View on a map |
|
Golden Pear
Make your way to the counter of this small, often-crowded café... Be the first to write a review |
$-$$ American |
Southampton
View on a map |
|
Hellenic Snack Bar
Heavenly homemade lemonade—well known on the North Fork—and... Be the first to write a review |
¢-$$ Greek |
Orient
View on a map |
|
Il Capuccino
Chianti bottles hang from the ceiling over tables draped in red-and-white-check... Write a review | Avg. member rating: 4.2/5 |
$$-$$$ Italian |
Sag Harbor
View on a map |
|
Inlet Cafe at Gosman's Dock
The view from the waterside tables and sushi bar is so mesmerizing... Be the first to write a review |
$-$$$ Seafood |
Montauk
View on a map |
|
Jamesport Country Kitchen
The food outshines the decor at this eatery, which looks like... Be the first to write a review |
$-$$ Contemporary |
Riverhead
View on a map |
|
John Duck Jr
This restaurant in a converted farmhouse on a terraced hill has... Be the first to write a review |
$$-$$$ American |
Southampton
View on a map |
|
La Parmigiana
Everyone seems to love this family-style place for its "red-sauce"... Be the first to write a review |
$-$$ Italian |
Southampton
View on a map |
|
La Superica
From the fresh lime juice in the margaritas to the fresh tuna... Be the first to write a review |
$-$$$ Mexican |
Sag Harbor
View on a map |
|
Lobster Roll
Set along the no-man's-land between Amagansett and Montauk, this... Be the first to write a review |
$-$$ Seafood |
Amagansett
View on a map |
|
Meetinghouse Creek Inn
The seafood at this waterside restaurant 4 mi east of Riverhead... Be the first to write a review |
$-$$ Continental |
Riverhead
View on a map |
|
Mirko's
The warm atmosphere and the talented chef-owner's use of only... | Reserve Online Be the first to write a review |
$$-$$$$ Eclectic |
Water Mill
View on a map |
|
Modern Snack Bar
At this unpretentious family-owned café beloved by locals... Be the first to write a review |
$-$$ American |
Riverhead
View on a map |
|
Napeague Stretch
You might feel as if you are standing on the deck of a fabulous... Be the first to write a review |
$-$$$ Seafood |
Amagansett
View on a map |
|
New Moon Cafe
This rustic, noisy restaurant has bright colors and lots of windows... Be the first to write a review |
$-$$$ Southwestern |
Quogue
View on a map |
|
New Paradise Café
You may browse the bookstore in front before walking to the restaurant... | Reserve Online Be the first to write a review |
$-$$$ American |
Sag Harbor
View on a map |
|
Nichols
This cozy, wooden-antiques-filled restaurant serves good, old-fashioned... Be the first to write a review |
$-$$$ American |
East Hampton
View on a map |
|
Orient by the Sea
The casual marina restaurant overlooks Gardiner's Bay. Dishes... Be the first to write a review |
$$-$$$ American |
Orient
View on a map |
|
Planet Bliss
You can't miss this brightly painted, funky restaurant in a converted... Be the first to write a review |
$-$$$ Eclectic |
Shelter Island
View on a map |
|
Q, a Thai Bistro
Inventive Thai cuisine and nightly Asian-fusion specials are... Be the first to write a review |
$$-$$$$ Thai |
Southampton
View on a map |
|
Rene's Casa Basso
Sculptures dot the front and side lawns of this upscale, traditional... Write a review | Avg. member rating: 5.0/5 |
$$-$$$ Italian |
Westhampton Beach
View on a map |
|
Salivar's
This dockside eatery serves classic diner food with a lot of... Be the first to write a review |
$-$$ American |
Montauk
View on a map |
|
Seafood Barge
The airy, nautically themed restaurant—one of the best... | Reserve Online Be the first to write a review |
$$-$$$ Contemporary |
Southold
View on a map |
|
Sen
An attractive, black-clad staff serves sushi and other Japanese... Be the first to write a review |
$-$$$ Japanese |
Sag Harbor
View on a map |
|
Shagwong Tavern
The specials at this local hangout next to Herb's Market change... Be the first to write a review |
$$-$$$ American |
Montauk
View on a map |
|
Turtle Crossing
Paintings of rodeo riders and dented old signs decorate the rustic... Be the first to write a review |
$-$$$ Southwestern |
East Hampton
View on a map |
|
Vine Street Cafe
Husband-and-wife team Terry and Lisa Harwood create casual but... | Reserve Online Be the first to write a review |
$$-$$$ Eclectic |
Shelter Island
View on a map |
|
World Pie
A friendly staff and mouthwatering Italian food make this down-to-earth... Be the first to write a review |
¢-$$ Italian |
Bridgehampton
View on a map |
Check hotel rates and airfares around the world- Travel Deals
-
Great hotel rates this Thanksgiving in NY, more — Up to 30% off
Hotels.com
-
Thanksgiving sale on hotels in NY, LA & more — Up to 30% off
Hotels.com
-
Thanksgiving sale on hotels in LA, NYC, more — Up to 30% off
Hotels.com
-
New York City Hotel: Advance Purchase Savings at Crowne Plaza Times Square - From $224
Crowne Plaza Times Square
- View All Travel Deals »
