Shelter Island Hotels

Read our Shelter Island hotel reviews. Or post your own.

Hotels Overview »

Name	Price	Location

Belle Crest Inn & Aimee's Cottage Built in the 1920s, the cozy inn decorated with period antiques... Be the first to write a review	$$$	Shelter Island View on a map

Chequit Inn The 1872 Victorian inn sits in the center of activity in the... Be the first to write a review	$-$$$	Shelter Island View on a map

Dering Harbor Inn With spectacular views of Dering Harbor, this co-op complex offers... Be the first to write a review	$$$-$$$$	Shelter Island View on a map

Olde Country Inn Privacy and romance are yours at this Victorian inn on a country... Be the first to write a review	$$-$$$$	Shelter Island View on a map

Pridwin The rambling, old-timey, family-friendly resort is on Crescent... Be the first to write a review	$$$	Shelter Island View on a map

Ram's Head Inn At this 1929 colonial-style inn, Adirondack chairs are scattered... Be the first to write a review	$-$$$$	Shelter Island View on a map

Sunset Beach An international crowd has flocked to this trendy hotel ever... Be the first to write a review	$$$$	Shelter Island View on a map
Hotels Overview »

For more travel ideas, tips, and deals, sign up for the Fodor's newsletter here. Read the current issue. Browse previous issues.