In the Dexter family for three generations, Polly's has been serving up pancakes and waffles (from its own original recipe) since the 1930s. Since then, smoked bacon and ham, sandwiches on homemade bread, delicious baked beans, and even gluten-free items have been added to the menu. There are even desserts such as raspberry pie. Much of the food is made from grains ground on-site. The gift shop sells maple products.