Nantucket Restaurants


Brotherhood of Thieves

The Brotherhood's Front Door

Brotherhood of Thieves Review

No, it's not really an 1840s whaling bar—though the atmospheric basement, which dates all the way back to 1972, presents a more convincing front than the newer, spiffier upper floors, which attract families and friendly singles alike. A swanky lounge was added in 2013, offering a tapas menu and a large and varied wine and craft beer selection. Upstairs or down, you can dive into the same juicy burgers and signature curly fries, and the entrées—such as peppercorn-crusted swordfish with a blue cheese potato cake—pack surprising sophistication. In summer, the lines trail down the block; in winter, it's a warm, inviting hideaway.

    Restaurant Details

  • Credit cards accepted.
Updated: 05-13-2013

Fodorite Reviews

Be the first to review this property


· Map of Brotherhood of Thieves

Map of

Travel Deals