Sign Up
Newsletter Signup
Free Fodor's Newsletter

Subscribe today for weekly travel inspiration, tips, and special offers.

Passport: Your weekly travel wrap-up
Today's Departure: Your daily dose of travel inspiration

Nantucket Restaurants

Brotherhood of Thieves

  • 23 Broad St. Map It
  • Nantucket Town
  • American

Updated 05/13/2013

Fodor's Review

No, it's not really an 1840s whaling bar—though the atmospheric basement, which dates all the way back to 1972, presents a more convincing front than the newer, spiffier upper floors, which attract families and friendly singles alike. A swanky lounge was added in 2013, offering a tapas menu and a large and varied wine and craft beer selection. Upstairs or down, you can dive into the same juicy burgers and signature curly fries, and the entrées—such as peppercorn-crusted

swordfish with a blue cheese potato cake—pack surprising sophistication. In summer, the lines trail down the block; in winter, it's a warm, inviting hideaway.

Read More

Restaurant Information


23 Broad St., Nantucket Town, Massachusetts, 02554, United States

Map It



Restaurant Details:

  • Credit cards accepted

Updated 05/13/2013


Map View

Map of

What's Nearby

  • Hotels
  • Restaurants
  • Sights

See all restaurants in Nantucket

Add Your Own Review

When did you go?

Minimum 200 character count

How many stars would you give?