Martha's Vineyard Hotels

Guidebooks

Kelley House

At a Glance

    Pros

  • Lots of historic charm, pretty gardens, some harbor views

    Cons

  • On street with lots of pedestrian traffic, pricey, frequent wedding locale

Fodor's Finds Hotels

Book Now

Kelley House Review

In the center of town, this sister property of the Harbor View combines services and amenities with a country-inn feel. A new owner for both properties has instituted a number of major improvements to the decor and facilities in 2007. The 1742 white clapboard main house and the adjacent Garden House are surrounded by pink roses. Large suites in the Chappaquiddick House and the two spacious town houses in the Wheel House have porches (most with harbor views) and living rooms. The Newes from America, a dark and cozy spot with original hand-hewn timbers and ballast-brick walls, serves typical pub victuals and microbrewed beers on tap.

    Hotel Amenities

  • 43 rooms, 11 suites.
  • Restaurant, bar, pool.
  • Rooms have: kitchen (some), Wi-Fi.
  • Rate includes breakfast.
  • Credit cards accepted.

Member Reviews

  • rndas, from Boston
    7/30/07

    The location of this hotel was great, but the room was pretty bad. It smelled damp, there was no hot water, and the power tripped if you used the hair dryer while the a/c was on (not expected of a larger, modern hotel). Also, their service was pretty bad - they forgot to make a brunch reservation for us at their sister hotel. That being said, the location in downtown Edgartown was great.

    Ratings details: Room: 2 | Atmosphere: 3 | Service: 1 | Value: 3
Add your own review

· Browse Martha's Vineyard hotels

By Price:

By Location

Travel Deals in Martha's Vineyard

View all travel deals

· Forums Trip Reports

View more trip reports

·,

View more travel discussions

· Travel Blog

View more blog stories