New Haven, Mystic, and the Coast Hotels


Old Mystic Inn

At a Glance


  • beautifully kept historic house
  • quiet neighborhood
  • friendly host


  • need a car to get into downtown

Old Mystic Inn Review

This 1784 inn was once a well-regarded bookstore, so it's no surprise that rooms in the cozy main house and carriage house are named after New England authors. Some have working fireplaces and whirlpool tubs, and each is a welcoming and comfortable mix of antiques and owner-innkeeper Michael Cardillo Jr.'s personal touches. You can enjoy a game of checkers by the oversize Colonial hearth in the keeping room; a full country breakfast is served.

    Hotel Details

  • 8 rooms
  • Rate includes breakfast.
  • Credit cards accepted.
Updated: 12-23-2013

Fodorite Reviews

Be the first to review this property


· Map of Old Mystic Inn

Map of

Travel Deals