It's rare to find hotel-style amenities in small-town heritage properties, but this place has them—and not just an elevator and an ice machine. Leading the list are the on-site restaurant—the cool, contemporary Tin Fish—and the full-service Aveda spa. Guest rooms are fully equipped, too, with DVD players, plush robes, and other conveniences. Pullout couches in most rooms, plus a pair of two-story lofts, make this property family-friendly. Back rooms on the fourth floor have postcard-quality harbor views.