This cheerful, family-run café comes with an authentic pedigree: the Colovattis are from the Italian city of Trieste, and the pizza is simply the best in the area. The crust is toasty crisp on the outside and chewy inside, topped with high-quality fixings and sauce made fresh every day. Calzones and homemade pastas are also on the menu, but pizza reigns supreme. Eat in the dining room—the fresh blue-and-white decor is reminiscent of the owners' hometown on the Adriatic Sea—or order takeout and bring your meal back to your hotel. The restaurant's rather odd name refers to the fact that this building used to be the post office. It's open 4 pm to 10 pm daily in high season and closed Tuesday in low season.
Main street, across from soccer field, Puerto Jiménez, 60702, Costa Rica