St. Thomas Restaurants

Guidebooks

Fodor's U.S. & British Virgin Islands, 23rd Edition

Craig and Sally's

Craig and Sally's Review

In the heart of Frenchtown, culinary wizard Sally Darash shows off her tasty creativity by never duplicating a menu. Her inspiration is pure local; it may start when a French fisherman shows up on her doorstep with a fish wiggling at the end of his speargun or when a community matriarch brings by bunches of fresh basil and thyme. The result may be a yellowfin tuna ceviche or roasted eggplant cheesecake with a basil chiffonade. Husband Craig, who has a wry humor, maintains a 300-bottle wine list that's won accolades.

Contact Information

Address: 22 Honduras St., Frenchtown, St. Thomas, 00802
Phone: 340/777--9949
Website: www.craigandsallys.com
Location: West End

Restaurant Details

Closed Mon. and Tues. No lunch weekends.

Member Reviews

gracie207, from Virgin Islands

7/1/10

Sometimes air conditioning is just more important than the view. When you throw in some of the best food and wine in the Caribbean, you know you're at C and S. Even if you're on a budget, don't miss it; go for lunch on Th/Fri, or go for tapas and martinis (they'll actually be cold)

Ratings details: Food: 5 | Atmosphere: 4 | Service: 5 | Value: 5
swhitey, from Boston

4/21/08

We've eaten everywhere on St. Thomas and Craig and Sally's is at the top. But it won't cost you an arm and a leg to eat there. Great food and value!

Ratings details: Food: 5 | Atmosphere: 5 | Service: 5 | Value: 5
dgodsill, from Con

3/15/08

Only restaurant we tried that lived up to expectations. Knowledgeable wait staff for both food and wine. Wines selection excellent with some reasonably priced.

Ratings details: Food: 5 | Atmosphere: 4 | Service: 5 | Value: 4
Beacher27, from Virginia

12/30/07

We have only positive things to say about our experiences here. We will surely return again and again, as will friends who regularly travel to STT. The food at Craig and Sally's is superb and our servers have been extremely attentive and knowledgeable.

Ratings details: Food: 5 | Atmosphere: 5 | Service: 5 | Value: 5
Carrybean, from USVI

11/8/07

I quit going after Craig once too often was sarcastic & snotty. Good food but not worth it.

Ratings details: Food: 4 | Atmosphere: 2 | Service: 1 | Value: 3
Lahdedah, from Laurens, SC

12/23/06

I don't like being treated as though they are doing me a favor by taking my money for over-priced, badly done food. I don't mind paying for quality but this place doesn't have it.

Ratings details: Food: 3 | Atmosphere: 3 | Service: 3 | Value: 2