Fodor's Expert Review Carringtons Inn

Editor's Note: This location is no longer in operation.

Local flavor, personalized service, and individual style make this intimate inn a welcome respite from the realm of cookie-cutter resorts, with its location in a former private home that offers a lovely pool and unbeatable ocean views. But ask repeat visitors why they keep coming back, and they'll point to owner Roger Carrington as the real reason to stay here: he serves delicious breakfasts—rum-soaked French toast is a house specialty—doles out advice, and makes you feel right at home. Each room is different, but amenities like four-poster beds, handwoven carpets, and colorful spreads are standard; there are balconies in some rooms, and either sea or pool views. The suburban, hillside location is a 10-minute drive from Christiansted, which means you need a rental car to explore or eat off property.