$$, St. John
Fodor's Review:
A stay here will allow you to live like a local in a middle-class residential neighborhood near a bird-filled salt pond. This cozy B&B is also an easy walk from Cruz Bay, which makes it convenient. White spreads and curtains provide pristine counterpoints to the blue-and-green hues in your room. Your hosts serve a delightful breakfast -- piña colada French toast is a specialty -- on the front deck. It's perfect for folks who enjoy peace and quiet: there are no phones or TVs in the rooms.
Visit the Travel Talk forums for help on planning your trip