Boasting "the friendliest wave on the island," the owners have maximized their private residence by converting their garage into overflow seating for this garden bistro. With fairy lights, beach chairs, and Latin music, the no-frills setting complements the simple menu of burgers, sandwiches, and signature dips. Flavorful creations include chipotle chicken, the peanut butter burger (just try it!) and for dessert, the grilled banana split. Owners John and Elaine Cosby refuse to reveal the secret of their rum punch recipe, which draws in a large clientele. The "Piña Lo-Lada" is the smoothest you'll ever taste. For an interesting keepsake, buy one of the souvenir T-shirts from each of the island's top surf spots. Ola Lola's is cash only.