Candles illuminate this tiny beachfront dining room during the four-course, prix-fixe affairs. The menu changes frequently but can include West Indian pumpkin or curried-apple soup; curried shrimp or three-mustard chicken; and, for dessert, rum bananas or key lime pie. Reservations are required by 4 PM for the single dinner seating at 7 PM. For lunch, you can get flying-fish sandwiches, hamburgers, and conch fritters at the Soggy Dollar Bar, famous as the purported birthplace of the lethal drink called the Painkiller.
Visit the Travel Talk forums for help on planning your trip >>