Choose one of four comfy island villas scattered on 11 acres of gardens, with access to the harbor and the beach, or go more upscale with a West Indies–style Flamingo Villa, perfectly situated across from the lighthouse at the entrance to the harbor. The spacious two-bedroom, two-bath villas have large kitchens, satellite TV, Internet access, deluxe bedrooms with balconies, and wraparound decks with pools and barbecues. The owners also run a property-management company that rents more than 75 private cottages and houses, including spectacular beachfront retreats at Tahiti Beach on the south end of the cay. Most of these units sleep four or more, and some of the more upscale properties can accurately be described as mansions. The management can also arrange for everything from kayak, boat, and golf-cart rentals to island excursions and fishing guides. All rentals have a four-night minimum stay.