Home Destinations Caribbean Bahamas Restaurants Blue Lagoon Seafood Restaurant

Blue Lagoon Seafood Restaurant Review

Read our Bahamas restaurant reviews. Or post your own.

Blue Lagoon Seafood Restaurant

$$-$$$, Seafood, New Providence Island

User Rating: ***** 4.8

Fodor's Review:

The decor tends toward the nautical, with hurricane lamps and brass rails, in this narrow third-floor dining room looking out to Nassau on one side and Atlantis to the other. Choose from simply prepared dishes such as broiled Bahamian lobster tail or grouper, or fancier selections such as almond-fried shrimp and stuffed grouper au gratin.

User Reviews & Ratings:

Great Value for Great Food

Posted by Lucy23 from Ohio on 4/18/08

My wife, daughter and I ate here in April 2008 and totally enjoyed ourselves. The food is excellent and the service, while deliberate, was very attentive. They even sang Happy Birthday to my daughter (totally embarrassing the 16 yr old!). Loved the crab claws, shrimp cocktail; they had a great lobster thermidor. We will definitely be back!

FOOD: 5.0

ATMOSPHERE: 5.0

SERVICE: 5.0

VALUE: 5.0

RATING: 5.0

FIne dining in Paradise

Posted by Tam75USA from New York on 2/1/08

Blue Lagoon Restaurant has an old world feel to it, reminiscent of the days when tourists to the islands wore dinner jackets. The food and service is outstanding; my party of seven had nothing but compliments for the various items were had for dinner, from stone crab claws to lobster to steak. The waiter even brought us Nassau Royale to finish the meal. I rate this restaurant very highly and recommend it to anyone.

FOOD: 5.0

ATMOSPHERE: 5.0

SERVICE: 5.0

VALUE: 5.0

RATING: 5.0

Excellent Food and Service!

Posted by Puravida1 from United States on 1/31/08

A local in Nassau recommended that I try the Blue Lagoon Restaurant located in Club Land'or. The food was great and reasonably priced for being in such a worldclass vacation area. The service was excellent and we didn't lack for anything. My filet was great, her grouper received high praise as well. Definitely try this one!

FOOD: 5.0

ATMOSPHERE: 5.0

SERVICE: 5.0

VALUE: 5.0

RATING: 5.0

To Die For!

Posted by freebird26 from Washington DC on 1/24/08

My husband and I had dinner here while visiting the Bahamas, the food was to die for! My husband had the filet minion, you could have cut it with a fork!!! I have the shrimp alfrado, it was faboulous! You must check this place out if you’re in the area!

FOOD: 5.0

ATMOSPHERE: 5.0

SERVICE: 5.0

VALUE: 5.0

RATING: 5.0

Wonderful Dining Experience

Posted by cruiseaholic from Charlotte, NC on 1/23/08

My husband, son and I ate at the Blue Lagoon Restaurant at Club Land'or on Paradise Island and thoroughly enjoyed ourselves. We were not rushed, and any special request we had was happily attended to (such as them heating my vichysoisse). The restaurant has an older, elegant feel to it, so if you want a loud joint with stuff on the walls go downtown to Hard Rock. We MUCH prefer this place and its wonderful Bahamian dishes, such as Grouper Amandine and great fresh lobster. We will definitely return and highly recommend the Blue Lagoon to anyone, whether celebrating an anniversary or other special occasion or just wanting a first class dining experience!

FOOD: 5.0

ATMOSPHERE: 5.0

SERVICE: 5.0

VALUE: 5.0

RATING: 5.0

Food was ok; but....

Posted by Rempsen from Canada on 1/1/08

When our meals finally came it was fairly good, my wife and I both had the surf and turf. The service and atmosphere require explanation for anyone expecting a fine dining experience. To be honest the restaurant feels like the fine dining night at any old folks home that you have ever been to. As long as you are OK with that or even like that the food as we said was pretty good...just know what your getting in to.

FOOD: 4.0

ATMOSPHERE: 2.0

SERVICE: 3.0

VALUE: 3.0

RATING: 3.2

Favorite Restaurant on Paradise island!

Posted by Butchsmom from The Midwest on 4/26/07

Husband, 12 year old and myself all love the food at this restaurant at Club Land'or on Paradise Island. Breakfast is delicious (blueberry pancakes) and reasonable, while the dinner menu is wonderful. Some of our favorites included steak au poivre, Chicken Eleuthera and a grilled tuna we had as a catch of the day. The service is very attentive and pleasant and we were not rushed like we were in the Atlantis restaurants. We will definitely eat here on our next trip to Nassau!

FOOD: 5.0

ATMOSPHERE: 5.0

SERVICE: 5.0

VALUE: 5.0

RATING: 5.0

Great Grouper!

Posted by Bill from USA on 4/18/06

My wife and I loved the waitstaff (they pampered us) and the food is outstanding. This restaurant is on the top floor of Club Land'or right beside Atlantis and it's worth the walk over. Be sure to try the seafood bisque!

FOOD: 5.0

ATMOSPHERE: 5.0

SERVICE: 5.0

VALUE: 5.0

RATING: 5.0