$, Long Island
Fodor's Review:
Six elevated cottages with generous bedrooms, bath, and airy screened porches line this remote Millers Bay beach location, halfway between Stella Maris and Deadman's Cay. Owners Pierre and Anne deliver exceptional personalized service; however, guests here should be self-sufficient and adventurous. Chef Pierre whips up fresh innovative dishes with homegrown ingredients and daily caught seafood in the relaxing oceanfront restaurant ($-$$). Explore nearby cays in sea kayaks, wade the adjacent flats for bonefish, or schedule a diving adventure through the Stella Maris marina. Fishing guides, car rentals, and airport transfers can be arranged.
Visit the Travel Talk forums for help on planning your trip