$$, St. George's Cay
Fodor's Review:
Abner Pinder's wife, Ruth, keeps these two attached two-bedroom houses as spotless as her own. A tiny, private sand beach overlooking Harbour Island is just steps from the patio. The house rental includes use of a golf cart so you can explore the island and pick up groceries at one of the local shops. There's a three-night minimum stay; it's $1,200 per house per week.
Visit the Travel Talk forums for help on planning your trip