$, Long Island
Fodor's Review:
Mellow and remote, the brightly painted two-story lodge consists of two thoughtfully constructed 600-square-foot guest studios downstairs that overlook a pristine beach and dramatic blue hole. There are dinette islands with stools, although you can also eat alfresco on your deck. The larger upstairs suite includes a full kitchen and private bedroom. At low tide, you can stroll the cove's entire beach and round the point into Clarence Town. You'll need to rent a car to stay here. Bonefishing guides and car rentals can be arranged by the manager, Nancy Knowles.
Visit the Travel Talk forums for help on planning your trip