Is Mexico Safe?
In the first of a series of articles on travel to Mexico, a Fodor's editor—with the help of a few Fodor's writers—weighs in on current safety south of the border.
If you only read mainstream news reports and official government travel-safety warnings, you probably aren't planning a trip to Mexico any time soon. H1N1 and drug violence do not a relaxing vacation make.
But if you look at a variety of sources, compare facts, and ask around, things aren't so clear. The answer to "is Mexico safe?" becomes "it depends"—as in, it depends on where you go and how you travel. It depends on how secure you feel moving through the world in general. And it depends on how diligent you are about taking precautions, some of which you should take wherever you travel.
The News: Bad and Ugly
I've been visiting Mexico for several years, but always to beach destinations, where you're often cocooned inside the walls—and security systems—of large resorts, where there are lots of other cringos, and where many of the locals speak English, work in the tourism industry, and have an interest in helping you to feel safe. On a recent trip to Mexico City—my first—however, I had some reservations.
Mexico has long and justifiably been known as a place of corruption and petty crime. Pickpockets there are skilled, as are credit-card and other scam artists. Although it's hard to get precise figures, robberies, carjackings, and rape are an issue, particularly in Mexico City. Kidnappings are seemingly less frequent but are nevertheless a concern—particularly libre-cab kidnappings (the driver of an unofficial cab—as opposed to a radio taxi or one at official stands or sitios—kidnaps a passenger for 24 to 48 hours, forcing him/her to make repeated ATM withdrawals).
It's also true that violent crime is rising, primarily due to President's Felipe Calderón's continuing war on the drug cartels (which, by the way, are also warring with each other). Estimates for 2008 put nationwide drug-cartel related deaths at a record high of between 5,000 and 6,000, with about 50% of them taking place in border regions.
There have been reports of firefights in Tijuana, Nogales, and Cuidad Juarez. Well down the Pacific coast, Acapulco has also seen an increase in disturbances since 2006. And parts of the central state of Michoacán are troubled as well.
A Little Perspective (And Some Numbers)
Here's the thing: the drug-cartel-related violence you read about is aimed at police or military personnel and cartel gang members, not tourists. It also generally takes place in rough neighborhoods rarely frequented by travelers. Further, there are few serious problems, in many parts of Mexico, including the major resorts of Cancún and the Caribbean coast, the Pacific coast, and southern Baja.
How did I feel in Mexico City? Well, it is a vast, often chaotic place—one where I don't speak the language and didn't know the territory. But I certainly wasn't afraid for my life. Indeed, I wasn't anywhere near as nervous as I expected to be. I listened to the guidance of the locals about where and when to be most on guard and how best to get around. I took my usual precautions (dress like a local, walk with confidence, wear cheap sunglasses to hide any worry in my eyes, carry only the minimum of cash and a single credit card—if that). I now have a better sense of the city and how to explore it safely, and I'm hoping to visit again soon.
The fact is, you're much more likely to die in a car accident in Mexico than any way else. Of the 681 non-natural, non-military deaths of United States citizens abroad recorded by the U.S. Department of State between July 1, 2006, and June 30, 2009, roughly 300 were listed as "Veh. Accident—Auto." Most of the 150 or so homicides listed took place in border regions. Indeed, a Google search of Mexico homicides for June 2009 showed that incidences (there were 6) on the state department's list for that month coincided with news reports of murdered Americans who were suspected of being involved with the Mexican cartels.
So Why Go?
It's important to heed the warnings about Mexico on the U.S. State Department Web site. But not everything is dark and gloomy. President Calderón has dedicated some 20,000 troops to deal with drug cartels, no small number and a nod to the fact that the government is taking this problem seriously. What's more, in 2008, 22.6 million people, including 5.8 million Americans, visited Mexico. Tourism is big business, so it's in the best interest of the country to keep travelers safe.
If you thoroughly research how and where (or not) to travel, listen to advice of those in the know, assess your tolerance to risk, and take the necessary precautions, you might just find a trip to Mexico safer than you thought.
What Fodor's Writers Say
I asked my writers for their takes on Mexico safety and for a few quick tips. What are your thoughts? Let us know in the comments.
Use Global Common Sense But Learn Local Tricks As Well
"In 10 years of living in Mexico City, and traveling throughout the country, I've had very few safety problems. I attribute this good fortune to the fact that I have native Mexican family and friends who've taught me good safety practices. Topping the list are these simple but important rules: follow all laws, pay close attention to the location of your wallet or purse—especially in crowded environments like metro stations and crowded buses, be discreet with your valuables, keep your cell phone handy, and let family and friends in on the details of your itinerary as well as your current location."
"Every region, every town, and every neighborhood in Mexico offers unique experiences and pleasures. And it's impossible to anticipate all of the safety concerns that could possibly arise. However, I have learned that simply asking lots and lots questions will not only turn up information that makes travel more interesting but yield useful tips for keeping safe as well.
- In Mexico City and other large cities, take a taxi operating from registered taxi stand, or sitio.
- Call friends to let them know your taxi number, which can be traced. Indeed, it's best to stay in frequent phone or email contact with others throughout your trip, especially when traveling alone.
- Always keep your embassy phone number with you. A call to the embassy will ensure that someone in a position of power knows where you are and what's happening in case of emergency.
- Avoid crowds at big celebrations and protests; depending on the political cause and climate, tourists may occasionally become the targets of anti-foreign sentiments.
- Be inquisitive: learn as much as you can about your environment, everywhere you go.
- Be cautious: don't assume anything will be like what you're accustomed to at home.
Michele Joyce has contributed to Fodor's Mexico since 2005. She holds a BA in Mexican History and Culture from UC Berkeley and an MA in Modern Art History from Casa Lamm.
Stay on the Beaten Path—But Don't Act Like a Tourist
"Is Mexico safe? Definitely. Mostly. There's no question that travel to Mexico requires extra vigilance for most of us. At home, we know which areas are safe and which aren't. We know who to turn to if we need help. We speak the language. We know the lay of the land. That's not the case in a foreign country. But paranoia isn't necessary. My work takes me all over Latin America, from the Río Grande south to Tierra del Fuego. Overall, I feel most secure in Mexico."
"If you're a Mexico novice, you can't go wrong with Los Cabos (just back from there), Puerto Vallarta, Ixtapa and Zihuatanejo, Cancún, Cozumel, and the Mayan Riviera. Sure, they live for tourism, but there's a safety in numbers and a security in their familiarity."
- Keep your passport, money, and credit cards well hidden.
- Leave flashy jewelry and expensive cameras at home.
- Stick to well-lit, busy streets.
- Walk purposefully, and step into a business to get your bearings (you'll definitely look like an outsider standing on a street corner with an open Fodor's guide.)
Costa Rica-based freelancer Jeffrey Van Fleet is a frequent traveler to Mexico, and has covered Los Cabos and Baja California for Fodor's. He has also written for Fodor's guides to Costa Rica, Guatemala, Panama, Peru, Chile, Argentina, and Central and South America.
"Overall, Mexico's reputation is undeserved. I recently traveled in Egypt, and my group had armed guards everywhere it went. Now that's a tad dangerous! Most of Mexico is very safe. The border areas are most affected by the drug wars (I certainly wouldn't go to Juarez), and if there is some sort of drug violence or serious crime, it generally doesn't take place in tourist areas."
"If you're nervous about Mexico, go to beach resorts like Cozumel, Cancun, the Riviera Maya, and so on. There are so many gringos around, you'll feel right at home."
- Stay aware of your surroundings. Don't wander around drunk. You're looking for trouble if you party late into the night and then stumble back to your hotel.
- Keep your dress low-key. (I dress like a backpacker—well, maybe a bit better than some).
Award-winning writer Maribeth Mellin, who contributes to Fodor's Cancún, has been traveling around and writing about Mexico for nearly three decades. Her column "Mexico: The Real Deal" appears in the San Diego News Network (SDNN.com)
Be Very Careful on Road Trips
"To avoid unwanted situations, stay clear of the border and avoid traveling long distances by car. In general, resorts are the best bet for a worry-free vacation since they usually have large staffs, 24-hour security, and in-room safes."
"Cancun and the Yucatan Peninsula, for example, are free of most dangers found in big cities. Cancun's Hotel Zone is a high-trafficked tourist area, making it extremely safe for those who want to relax at the beach or explore the string of shops and restaurants that line Boulevard Kukulcán. Downtown Cancun (El Centro) is equally safe at night, especially in the upper class section from Avenida. Tulum to Avenida Bonampak. That said, avoid Avenida Yachilan and the sector beyond Chichen Itza at night. The area of Las Palapas is somewhat questionable as well."
- Whether you're driving or walking, be mindful of local drivers. There aren't always sidewalks, traffic moves fast, and not everyone thinks the rules of the road apply to them.
- Avoid desolate Mexican beaches, which can be just as dangerous as dark back-alleys. On empty coastlines you're susceptible to theft.
- Always respect the warning flags posted on beaches. Most hotel beaches have lifeguards, but as with all ocean swimming, use common sense—even the calmest-looking waters can have strong currents and riptides.
Marlise Elizabeth Kast has contributed to over 50 publications including Forbes, Surfer, San Diego Magazine and the New York Post. She has also contributed to Fodor's guides to Cancun, Mexico, Puerto Rico, Panama, and San Diego.
Tourists Are Not the Target
"The American news coverage of Mexico's drug violence has made the problem seem more widespread than it is. The likelihood of a visitor encountering this violence is remote; the targets are the police, the army, and other gang members, not ordinary citizens or tourists. Living in the central part of the country, our only exposure has been what we've seen and heard on television. Our town of San Miguel de Allende and the surrounding area seem as safe as ever."
"Other types of crime don't seem to be on the increase. And, having recently traveled to Guatemala, we can say that crime against individuals is much more of a problem there. Visitors to Mexico should exercise the same precautions they would anywhere (including the United States). . . prudence is always a good idea."
Gerard Helferich and Teresa Nicholas are contributors to Fodor's Guatemala, and for the past seven years, residents of San Miguel de Allende, Mexico.
Take Advantage of the Drop in Visitors
"Traveling in Mexico, like traveling in any new place, requires an initial period of awareness and discovery: how do local people behave? Which parts of town are full of life, and which should you avoid at night? Baja Norte is as friendly and beautiful as ever—beyond an increase in crime in Tijuana, the most notable change is the drop in visitors across the entire peninsula. Take the obvious precautions, but enjoy the trip!"
California-based writer Coco Krumme has covered Mexico—in particular Baja—for Fodor's since 2005.
Look Both Ways
"For the most part, Mexico is a safe travel destination. Keep in mind that much of what you hear in the news these days is drug-related violence.... The safest bets, of course, are the large-scale tourist resorts.... Some final words of caution: always look both ways before crossing the street. It's a sound rule of thumb in a nation where many drivers tend to see a stoplight as a mere suggestion."
John Hecht, is a correspondent for The Hollywood Reporter who lives in Mexico City. He has contributed to Fodor's Cancún.
Photo courtesy of istock / andres balcazar
Member Comments (5) Post a Comment
I live in El Paso, TX but cross the border every day to Juarez, Mexico where I work. Over the past several years, the safety of the city has changed drastically. While I have gotten used to the military presence, many days it feels like the war zone that it has become. The convoys remind me clips of Iraq rather than an image of Mexico.
It’s true that the cartels are targeting each other, but it is easy to get caught in the crossfire. Violence is not limited to “bad” areas of town or at night. I have seen the aftermath of several shootings on normal streets near schools and parks on weekday afternoons. One employee that reports to me came in shaken the day after she saw two gunmen shoot and kill four police officers at 4pm on a busy street in front of a new mall. Another employee of mine asked for time off because his cousin was shot when the gunmen were actually after his cousin’s friend.
Scarier yet are the kidnappings. Anyone perceived to have money, even a little money, is a target. Anything from a nice car to a management position to a bank account containing a couple thousand dollars can catch the eye of a kidnapper or one of their many informants. Two Mexican managers at the small plant where I work have been victims in the past year.
Even locals are scared, and no one knows who to trust.
I continue to go to work, but I know it is a matter of luck and timing that is keeping me safe. I would not recommend visiting Ciudad Juarez to the casual traveler.
On the flip side, I would highly recommend visiting one of the tourist locations away from the border. Violence, swine flu, and the weak economy all have hurt the tourism industry in Mexico. Deals are common and fewer crowds make it easier to enjoy tourist destinations at a great price.
My husband, son, and I visited Puerto Vallarta in July and were pleasantly surprised by the bargains we found. We took a water taxi to the small village of Yelapa and ended up with the boat almost to ourselves when they are normally packed with people. Instead of chatting tourists, we could hear the scampering crabs and the singing birds on our hike to the Yelapa waterfall. The natural pool below the waterfall was all ours. Back at the Yelapa beach, the restaurant owners offered their best prices, best service, and best seats because they had so few customers. Violence is not prevalent there. But while other tourists stayed home in fear, we relaxed on a beach as quiet and tranquil as those in the Corona commercials.
Perhaps I'm cynical, but the only Mexican part of laying on a beach in a resort area (Cancun, PR, Acapulco, etc.) is that you are physically in Mexico. You often see more gringos than Mexicans. If you go for the beach and relaxation, great. If you go because you love the culture, want to engage with the people, and want to experience authentic Mexico, you're not going to find it at the resorts.
I'm a gringo and my wife is Mexican, and we have travelled extensively along the Pacific coast of Mexico, usually by car and usually to places well off the beaten path. Do we experience authentic Mexico - you bet! Are we taking on a greater safety risk than bumming around a beach resort - you bet!
The bottom line is that you need to reconcile how safe you want to be with how much of the culture you want to experience.
Postcript: my wife and I were planning to rent a car and tour the Baja. We scrapped it - too many reports of kidnappings and car jackings in the Baja.
In the last three years since my wife and I returned to travelling, especially to Mexico again, we have not once had any problems with crime in Mexico. Now, we tend to frequent the tourist areas of Mazatlan and Puerto Vallarta, and I can tell you there is a different type of "criminal" praying on people. I am talking about the timeshare sales people who pray on uninformed tourists who have no idea of the "real" value of a timeshare. Maybe the Off Premises Contacts are a bother to tourists, but at least they are friendly and still aren't really criminals. They are just trying to earn a living.
It has never been unsafe in the past 6 months to travel to tourist areas of Mexico, Baja or Cancun, nor is the threat of drug violence a meaningful deterent. There are certainly more violent drug problems in major US cities than in Cancun, plus today you need to worry in the US about recent terrorist activities. Cancun enjoyed 26 straight months of tourism increases until false media storm about H1N1, now we've had 5 straight months of double digit decreases. Mexico and Cancun are great vacation destinations, considerably less expensive than most other destinations with first class amentities and the people are great.
I am a gringo from California and my wife (Mexican) and I own a small bed and breakfast in Oaxaca.
We have had hundreds of guests stay with us over the past 5 years and have not had one incident of theft or violence. We always advise our guests to be careful with valuables, but we would do the same if our B and B was in any large city in the world.
I can't say that there is no crime here in southern Mexico--because there certainly is. But, I can say that I feel safer walking here in the center of the city than I do walking in the downtown area of most large US cities.
Lastly, if you want a relaxing beach vacation with other gringos, go to the Mexican beach resorts and feel safe. If you want to experience the incredibly rich culture, the cheap prices, the friendly Mexican people, and a wonderful climate, visit the colonial cities of southern Mexico and know that you can do so without feeling fear.
Fodor's Top News & Features
- World's Best Honeymoon Destinations for 2014
- 15 Things Not to Do in Paris
- The 7 Best Family Beaches in the East
- World's Craziest Bar Concepts
- 7 Best Warm Weather Trips Without a Passport
- 10 Best All-Inclusive Resorts in the Caribbean
- Ten Things NOT to Do in Italy
- 20 Ultimate Things to Do in New York City
- A Fool-Proof Amalfi Coast Itinerary
- $99 & up -- Hotel Deals Across Arizona through WinterVisit Arizona
- $89 -- 4-Star Minneapolis Hotel w/Breakfast & Wi-Fi, 50% OffThe Hotel Minneapolis
- $159 -- Savannah: Riverfront Hotel w/Bottle of Wine, 50% OffCotton Sail Hotel
- $129 -- Weekends at Portland 4-Star Boutique Hotel w/ValetTravel Portland
- $199 & up -- Norwegian Cruise Sale w/Choice of ExtrasNorwegian Cruise Line
- $199 & up -- 4-Star Westin Times Square Hotel, 25% OffThe Westin New York At Times Square