A Fodorite (who will go unnamed) posted that the best banana/macadamia pancakes on the island were NOT Kountry Kitchen – but were to be found on the other side of Kapa’a at Ono Family Restaurant. I knew it was my duty to take the task of comparing upon myself. (It was a sacrifice, but somebody had to do it 
)
I went with a wee bit of trepidation—and great anticipation—to taste these amazing pancakes. (I admit, I whimpered a bit as I drove past the line of people outside Kountry Kitchen.)
Ono was crowded and the waitresses and hostess seemed overwhelmed and disorganized. I waited thirty minutes for one of the two outside tables—that had been empty the entire time I waited.
But who cares? I was about to have the best pancakes on the island.
I ordered the a short stack of the “tropical” pancakes—described as a banana/macadamia nut batter topped with sliced bananas and coconut.
What did I think? They were “good”—not amazing; not OMG; not I’ve got to tell my friends about this and go back again and again … And sadly, for my taste, not even in the same league as Kountry Kitchen.
They were a different approach—and different people like different flavors and textures; some like vanilla—some prefer chocolate; some will vote for Romney—and some for Obama; and some people simply have no taste at all! .
The massive Kountry Kitchen banana w/added mac pancakes are impossibly light, and the batter is redolent with bananas and macadamias. At times, I have thought they were among the best things that have ever been in my mouth!
The Ono Family Restaurant pancakes are 60% the size of KK’s (but that doesn’t matter because I ordered two, instead of one) and are chewier; heavier; more textured. The coconut was a nice touch. But I didn’t detect any bananas in the batter—and there was a mere smattering of macadamia nuts; not even half of what was included in the KK version.
For me, there’s no contest. Not even close. KK wins hands down.
The Great Kauai Pancake Debate
Recent Activity
View all United States activity »
- 1 San Francisco - one semi-splurge restaurant?
- 2 Finally, seeing the Outer Banks
- 3 Need help with itinerary to Seattle, Oregon, California
- 4 Luggage stolen from locked rental car in Orlando
- 5 Yellowstone Snow Melt, Roads and Trails - Timing
- 6 San Fran, Napa, Palo Alto, Carmel advice
- 7
Rocks and Roads in Utah
- 8
First-time to NYC Trip Report as promised!
- 9 2 Brits Travelling USA July-Aug 2013
- 10 Stay between San Francisco and Redwoods?
- 11 Using public transit in San Diego
- 12 1st time in Boston --need advice
- 13 New Orleans trip (plus road trip) Help Pls!
- 14 Memphis Tours
- 15 D.C. in a day
- 16 Ideas for Northern California trip?
- 17 What to do with extra day in Virginia?
- 18
A Visit to Charleston
- 19 Cedar Point Wait Times
- 20 time for a new countdown to Hawaii
- 21 How far ahead to book Alcatraz?
- 22 San Francisco Anniversary Trip
- 23 NYC Newbie Needs Advice Re JFK Transportation
- 24 Florida to Yellowstone to Mt. Rushmore-Sept 2013
- 25 3 Week Roadtrip Starting in Nashville - Where to Go?!
Oh come on. Name Names. lol
Why not name names? If it was me, then I'm fine with you not liking them. Different strokes for different folks!! I also live Olympic Cafe, but my friend iamq had a terrible experience there We are still friends, but I won't take him to the oly cafe with me. Have you tried the pancakes at tip top cafe? Keep up the quest!!! Aloha
<Why not name names?>
Because I can't the post where someone said they preferred Ono & Tip Top!!!
But continuing on my quest I hope to check out Tip Top either this time or in January. (I've been there but didn't order the pancakes.)
Heres the secret to good pancakes, IMOP. Do not use the lowfat buttermilk that most stores carry and market. Use the higher fat content, sometimes referred to as Bulgarian Style Buttermilk. This is a thicker and slightly different taste to it. I think it has more bacteria cultures in it as well-Perhaps like different yogurts do. Using the higher fat will result in fluffier lighter pancakes.
Now there is a billion different ways to top them. If you use fresh pineapple in anything, it can throw a recipe way off. Just try to get fresh pineapple to gel in Jello, for example. Kiwi has similar properties.
iamq is not the only ones who dislikes the Olympic Cafe!
My vote is for Kountry Kitchen too. (doesn't mean much though, cuz I haven't had pancakes anywhere else on the island)
I wonderrrrrr if s'doc got the Haole Special MacNut Plate?
Never been a big fan of either place but do love my Oly Cafe and the Bloody Marys.
Not to mention the HUGE fruit plates, salads and kalua pork.
My fave cooking is at some of my Local friend's houses. They have spolied us over the years.
Maybe I'll be the final judge in about 70ish more days?
22tango - I was going to say exactly the same thing! (and even though they were out of macadamia nuts when we were there!)
Kal, kal, kal.....we're talking pancakes here!!!!!!!
I've never left the Olympic Cafe hungry (or thirsty), that's for sure.
Why anyone would leave Hanalei for any reason (including pancakes) is beyond me.
Um, at the risk of being booed off the stage, are there any pancake varieties that don't have macadamia nuts in them? I just don't care for them. Pineapple, coconut... bring 'em on, but those little nutty buggers do nothing for me. (Neither does coffee. But that's more for the rest of you, right?)
I've always thought that the good ole regular no-fills pancakes at the Hanalei Wake Up were pretty damn good. That and a side of Porteguese sausage can keep one satisfied until lunch at Pat's Taqueria at noon.
meant "no frills"...plenty o fills...
WW, I say stay in Kapaa and walk next door to the Ono, down the street to The Oly and across the street to Kauai Pasta!!! Not to mention being almost next door to The Pono Market!! It's Ono at the Pono!!
It's Finer in Hanaliner.
But, you gotta leave your attituda at Bar-a-Cuda or they might be ruda to youda!!!!!
I think I was the person that said I don't like KK. Never been a fan. Lot's of people are. Not going to talk stink about them, but will likely not return.
Now Oly Cafe I like. Their coffee can be awful or wonderful and much of the menu is mediocre, but I love sitting on either side of the restaurant and taking it all in from above. That iamq probably didn't know how to order. We've done well to order one pancake with added blueberries to the ban/mac and a couple of over easy eggs. Man oh man are those rooster eggs farm fresh!!! And oh so very yokey! I never knew they made a mean Bloody Mary. Bloody Mary's and breakfast usually mean food coma to me so I like to just eat the garnishes.
Truth be told, I have never once in all of my educational visits tried loco moco. It both scares me and intrigues me, but not enough to cross over and order it. Where oh where would one go to have the only loco moco of their life?
Remember when Auntie Maria and pokeporkchop had the Loco Moco tasteoff in Honolulu? Don't remember which place won.
I don't do the loco moco, but DH does. I'm certain he has had them at Kalapaki Beach Hut and at Tip Top, but don't know about other places. However, he likes the non traditional one at Ono which has kalua pork over fried rice and the eggs with the gravy on the side which I don't remember him using.
One thing fer sure in Hawaii, at breakfast, if the surfs up, the busboy may be manning the kitchen while the linecook is riding a wave.
Speaking of pancakes. . .
http://thegardenisland.com/entertainment/night-life/tip-top-your-way-to-a-delicious-meal/article_0875cec2-2092-11e2-92f5-001a4bcf887a.html
KK wins on the pancakes! Need my coconut syrup on top, too.
Absolutely gotta have the coconut syrup!
So, Songdoc, you been anywhere else yet to do your pancake research?
Al and Don's had some good pancakes too. The Royal Hawaiian.
Bananas, pineapples, papayas and MacNuts. Coconut syrrrrrrup.
"The Bobby" was the Chief Cook and Bottle washer there for years. Sad that place is closed now. Nice ocean view, right on the beach.
They filmed part of "Tropic Thuder" inside the restaurant.
Tall Tales from The Blue Book Bible from Hell
Seems pretty Andy got rid of his cowriter/partner, or did she simply run for the hills? I've never found the answer to the question of her demise of being left of of future editions of the book she helped write.
Now he is selling the building and land (or land rights - real estate in hell is very confusing) under his sister and bro inlaw partners of Scotty's BBQ
Little Andy sure has a way of attracting trouble in paradise.
I apologize. I've let you all down in my quest. On my last day in paradise (Halloween) I returned to Kountry Kitchen. For my $$$ .... it's unbeatable. That breakfast was the best meal of my trip. (with Hamura's saimin running a close 2nd)
You gotta go with what you love!!!
Lookin Glass, I also wondered what happened to his partner Harriet.
From what I read, Scotty's is still open and looking to move to a new location.
Scotty's is way over rated, just like those damn books.
Does Scotty's still run out of BBQ about 2-3 hrs after opening? Happened to us 2-3 diff times. WTH???
LOL. Only Songdoc can get it going with a debate about pancakes - and I immediately thought that the most important thing for good Hawaiian pancakes is the Coconut syrup - which several others mentioned.
see: http://tinyurl.com/ce4myj5
Used to have a favorite place years ago - a couple blocks off the beach in Waikiki - but think they are gone now. First time had Coconut syrup - and now buy a bottle to take home every trip.
Hey - the North Shore (Bali Hai) of Kauai is No Ka Oi- and you only leave it to explore some more of the beautiful Garden Isle - but always return.
Kal, I never got Scotty's. You really like them? We went to the buffet one Sunday and I thought and it was pretty average. Consider the source though, this is coming from someone who is not crazy about your Holy Grail, The Oly (Grail)Cafe. You do have good taste buds though. Anyone who likes the Tipsy Pig is okay in my book.
WW, you should have gone down the street to the Ono Family Restaurant. Scotty's is for bbq...NOT breakfast!!! We have eaten at Scotty's a couple of times and liked it ok. Great view!
Also Sondoc: Thanks for the great tip on what kind of Buttermilk to use in the pancakes. Have to try that.
"Use the higher fat content, sometimes referred to as Bulgarian Style Buttermilk. "
iceu2, It wasn't breakfast! It was their "buffet". Ribs, chicken, etc, etc....The only place for breakfast on that wretched place is the Hanalei Wake-Up and Village Snack Shop, but those are up in Hanalei and you Kapaa lovers never get that far.
Oopsie daizy!!!! Didn't even know they had a buffet!!! I think we have only had a sandwich there..
...
iceu2, Where are you going to have your _ _th birthday dinner?
hmmm, I had my _ _th at The Beach House. Where do you suggest for the _ _th? Needs to be somewhere that I can just roll home unless you are coming to be the DD!!
How about Hukilau Lanai? You could roll like a ball home from there.
If the real icee doesn't drink too much, how about driving up to the Tavern on the Princeville golf course. Great sunset views and their food is exceptional.
That's an idea, WW! We have some friends that are going to be there and they don't drink!!!! Yippee, I think I do see a DD driver in my birthday plans!!!!