My husband and I are visiting New Orleans with 2 other couples in October 2001. Second visit for me, first for everyone else. We have reservations at St. Vincent's Guest House. Looking for feedback on service, cleanliness, convenience and safety of neighborhood. We are staying for a week, want something charming, but are on a budget (would rather spend money on food and entertainment!)
St. Vincent's Gues House, New Orleans
Recent Activity
View all United States activity »
- 1 3 Week Roadtrip Starting in Nashville - Where to Go?!
- 2
Boston, my 2 hour food shopping spree to satiate my man's needs
- 3 1st time in Boston --need advice
- 4 NYC Newbie Needs Advice Re JFK Transportation
- 5 New Orleans trip (plus road trip) Help Pls!
- 6 How similar are the San Juan Islands and the Tofino area of B.C.?
- 7 Florida to Yellowstone to Mt. Rushmore-Sept 2013
- 8
A Visit to Charleston
- 9 Oregon & Washington: What are we missing, as we're big fans already?
- 10 Pine or Deckers as a place to meet (Lost Creek Wilderness)
- 11 Finally, seeing the Outer Banks
- 12
DC with Kids Trip Report
- 13 Using public transit in San Diego
- 14 Luggage stolen from locked rental car in Orlando
- 15
1st time to Kauai! Will not be the last!
- 16 Seattle Hotel Choice and Other Questions
- 17 Erie Canal - Finger Lakes Region - Day Trip?
- 18 Girls Getaway Suggestions?- Wisconsin Dells
- 19 Wisconsin Dells with teenagers
- 20 Best places to stop New Orleans to Los Angeles
- 21 10 days after cruise - Fort Lauderdale Fly out from LA?????
- 22 Lake Tahoe
- 23 Baseball Road Trip
- 24
First-time to NYC Trip Report as promised!
- 25
Moab and Bluff


Sharon, I am sorry to say that St. Vincent's gets TERRIBLE reviews. In fact, I've yet to see a positive thing written about it other than "it's cheap." Don't expect cleanliness or service and the neighborhood is somewhat inconvenient to the French Quarter or nice parts of the Garden District. I'd definitely keep looking as I think you'll be very disappointed.
John, thanks for your quick reply. do you have any suggestions for better places that are moderately priced?
Sharon
Sharon, what are your specific dates? October is a VERY busy month and prices are higher.
dates vary slightly by couple
10/10-10/17
10/10-10/16
10/13-10/17
We all want to stay in the same place.
I have found two others with availability - one is Fauberg Guest Suite on Frenchman St. and one is Cotton Brokers houses on Esplanade and Bayou. Are you familiar with facilities and/or locations?
We like to walk so would like to be in areas where we can walk to and from French quarter and other sites. etc.
thanks again for your help
Sharon
Sharon, those are tough dates because of conventions but then again you already know this!
You can't walk to the Quarter from Cotton Brokers or from St Vincents. You can from Faubourg Guest Suite. I'll throw in another one to consider: The Suites at 824 Elysian Fields, www.824ef.com.
Good luck!
Sharon, The St. Vincent Guest House is horrible. I've stayed in small hotels, hostels and backpacker places (literally) around the world and this was my worst experience. It was so bad we even sent letters to the BBB and NOLA Tourist & Convention Association. It is rundown to the point tacky with such as curtin rods hanging from the walls, dirty bed linens (one of our people found lipstick on what was supposed to be a clean bed); some of the facilities did not work properly (a/c, TVs, phones, showers). The swiming pool was dirty even AFTER they cleaned it. And the management is indifferent to downright insulting. We were a group of 25 that made the mistake of staying there this past July, so it wasn't just one room that was bad, it was several. I'd cancel my reservation and look for another place. Even though you didn't ask, you might make it a point to have at least one of your meals at Mulate's on Julia Street--right across from the Riverwalk. They were excellent and treated our group just fine. Hope you and your friends enjoy your visit.
Sharon--here's a P.S. to my previous message. Go to the following web site for a listing of some moderate (and expensive) hotels. www.aroomforyou.com/new-orleans-hotels.htm
The Hampton Inn is suppossed to be good. If all else fails, you could even spend the night in one of the Quality Inns, Holiday Inns or there's a Days Inn right on Canal street. After I re-read my note realized it should be Curt"a"in rod, swimMing pool and "...to the point of being tacky." See what happens when you get all fired up and start banging away on the keys. "That place" made me a strong believer in checking out some websites before trying these "cutesy" places again. If you want some more info, go to Frommer's site, US, Louisiana for additional input on NOLA and "that place." Cheers to you and your fellow travelers.
Sharon, take John's advice and check his possibility. My suggestion is to visit New Orleans on some other dates if you're not locked into those dates that you listed. If you are locked into those dates, you possibly might find rooms cheaper than they are now, by watching the discounters closely. Sometimes hotels at the last minute drop prices for rooms that they had blocked for the conventions and at the last minute release them. Good luck, but those prices you see out there are too high for a leisure trip if your budget is tight.
I'd like to second Pete's advice to take any recommendation John makes. I've been going to New Orleans for 40 years and John's advice is first rate.