United States Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

Trip Report Palmetto-ing to Charleston SC- - Contrasted With New Orleans

Jump to last reply

*Logistics*

This year, in conjunction with a visit to my parents in the Washington DC ‘burbs for Christmas, I decided to tag on a visit to Charleston…a city that prior to December 27th I had never seen before. My uncle lives in nearby Beaufort SC but his girlfriend lives in Charleston, so a major reason for this trip was to pay them a long overdue visit. Since I very much enjoy train rides, I opted to take the daytime Palmetto train from DC and returned northward from Charleston to New York City via the overnight Silver Meteor sleeper train.

*Introduction and Contrast with New Orleans*

Prior to this visit, I had imagined Charleston to be very much like New Orleans, both venerable historic Southern cities with roughly similar vegetation and climates, both known for their architecture and cuisine. What I discovered however is while the two cities mentioned in “Gone with the Wind” share the above in common, to my eyes, they have saliently different personalities.

The predominant right angles and crisp lines of Charleston’s streets, buildings and shutters bespeak of a degree of 19th century uniformity. The buildings in Charleston I found to be immaculate, stately, and imposing, which led me to think of the words “patrician”, “haughty” and even “square”. There seemed to exude a quest for perfection in the pristineness and the grandeur ubiquitous throughout the city’s core. New Orleans in contrast seemed to me to be less planned, more organic in its formation, which created more of a mish-mash, a patchwork quilt of architectural style. While certainly, there are pockets of genteelness, and equally stately, patrician-seeming buildings peppered throughout New Orleans, there’s something more laid-back and laissez les bons temps rouler (sorry to repeat that cliché expression) about the overall vibe of the Crescent City.

Perhaps you might think after reading the last paragraph that I had a negative impression of Charleston. Au contraire, as I appreciate friends whose characters differ in ways similar to these two cities, I appreciated the cities for their differences too. I greatly respected that Charlestonians have been so diligent and remarkably successful in their efforts of preserving the character of the walk-able historic downtown peninsula. While the unremitting elegance of the “elite”-seeming neighbourhoods south of Calhoun Street might lead one to imagine the populace looking down their nose at those “not in the club”, I found those I interacted with in Charleston to have an unflagging hospitality and easy friendliness. Plus, I’ll spell it out: Charleston is a beautiful city at the confluence of the Ashley & Cooper Rivers, with palmettos, more than a smattering of cobblestone/brick streets, genteel parks/fountains and unrelentingly handsome architecture. It was seemingly impossible for me to NOT be seduced as I ambled through the storied streets.

*Coming up… Coming via the Palmetto… Also, what did I do in Charleston? Where did I stay in Charleston? *

22 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

  • Announcement:
  • Fodor's Go List 2015 Has Been Announced
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Dec 19, 14 at 05:08 PM
View all United States activity »
  1. 1 Itinerary ideas for Niagara Falls via Corning/Watkins from NYC
  2. 2 bachelors degree
  3. 3 San Diego One Day Itinerary
  4. 4 How the fairytale of New York can become a nightmare
  5. 5 Has anyone been getting ads for handguns/holsters?
  6. 6 Hang out, Low Key, Getaway Area?
  7. 7 Has anyone been to Li'l Dizzy's in the Treme?
  8. 8 First Time RVing - Is my itinerary on overkill for 10 day trip?
  9. 9 Please help identify location in Southern California
  10. 10 Getting to Key West
  11. 11 Is Coral Gables or Miami a shorter distance to the Everglades?
  12. 12 historic small western towns - with shopping district, dino digs??
  13. 13 West Maui Restaurants
  14. 14 New Hawaii countdown for 2014-15
  15. 15 Trip Report 62 Hikers airlifted out of Kalalau Trail
  16. 16 New Orleans Motel Question
  17. 17 Help with seeing Rocky Mountain National Park
  18. 18 San Francisco Italian Restaurant for 14
  19. 19 3 weeks in USA in February -- final post before booking hotels
  20. 20 Indoor Waterpark in Wisconsin Dells ?
  21. 21 Recommendations for things to do near San Diego Marriott Marquis & Marina
  22. 22 fly fishing spring break - warm weather
  23. 23 Best non-tourist trap restaurants in South Beach
  24. 24 Happy Hour
  25. 25 Wisconsin Dells, Lake Geneva or Door county for a family vacation?
View next 25 » Back to the top