United States Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

Opinions on these budget hotels?

Jump to last reply

Message: We are travelling from Australia to New York next September and would like to know if anyone has stayed in these budget hotels. We are looking for something with a private bathroom, clean and in a safe area. Any opinions on these would be appreciated: The Hotel Wolcott, Herald Square, Portland square, Carlton Arms, Pioneer Hotel, Malibu Studios, Senton Hotel. Or any other suggestions for under $100 a night.

1 Reply |

Add a Reply
  • Report Abuse

    I'm familiar wioht the first three and have always heard that they are acceptable tourist class budget hotels - safe and clean but very plain and not fancy. Of the rmeaining three I've only heard of Maibu Studios and recall seeing mixed reports but it should be easy to find by searching this forum - it has been discussed here. Grand Union is in the same general area as the Wolcott and is similar in price and reputation. The Hotel Madison gets good reviews here as a budget property including comments from a fellow Aussie (Alan Jarman) who posted here about staying there with his family. I have also read a favorable review of Hotel 41 on 41st Street just below Times Square. It's a new property with small rooms but said to be clean and nice (it's an odd and mostly commercial block but an incredibly convenient location). If there are only two of you and you're okay with having one bed you should consider Priceline. You could do pretty well and most likely get a 3* property for well under $100 per night - somethign much nicer than the budget places you mention. Theoretically I save lots of money when I use Priceline but the reality (which is fine for me!) is that I now stay in much nicer properties than I did before and spend about the same (but quite often a bit less). I never, ever stayed in Marriott's, Hyatt's or Hilton's in the past but I do so now because I'm paying about what I paid for lower end chains.

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

  • Announcements:
  • Writers Needed for Mexico
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Jul 24, 14 at 12:19 PM
  • Writers Needed for Georgia Coast
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Jul 18, 14 at 03:12 PM
  • Writers Needed for Rwanda and Uganda
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Jul 18, 14 at 03:12 PM
View all United States activity »
  1. 1 Atascadero -> Pacific Grove -> San Francisco
  2. 2 Day trip to CT from NYC
  3. 3 Santa Barbara, California
  4. 4 Fear of driving in San Francisco/USA
  5. 5 Zion Narrows - Relatively Easy / Suitable for Older Folks?
  6. 6 Central Park Fall Foliage
  7. 7 Historic Houses & Sites near Charleston & Savannah.
  8. 8 Trip Report Another Californian Odyssey (June/July 2014)
  9. 9 Trip Report Trip Report: New York City July 25-27, 2014
  10. 10 vegas with two teens 13 & 14yo
  11. 11 Amtrak Train from California to Oregon or Washington
  12. 12 San Fran to Las Vegas drive
  13. 13 Los Angeles itinerary for August trip
  14. 14 A weekend escape around cooperstown ny
  15. 15 Road Trip SW
  16. 16 let's do a new Hawaii countdown
  17. 17 California road trip
  18. 18 Seattle, Portland, and day trips all around
  19. 19 Keystone, CO & area - inside activities?
  20. 20 Hiking Arches or Canyonlands National Park in fall?
  21. 21 Another Southwest Airlines Early Bird Question
  22. 22 Kauai -- Music Lovers!!!
  23. 23 Gulf Shores Restaurants
  24. 24 Yosemite Fire
  25. 25 Lodging - Yosemite
View next 25 » Back to the top